Why do primal eaters believe dairy products are ok for consumption? - PaleoHacks.com

Why do primal eaters believe dairy products are ok for consumption?

2012-10-21T15:18:05Z

People who follow the primal lifestyle clearly pay a lot of attention to food and health but they still eat dairy despite the fact that it has hormones that aren't good for us and raise insulin. What are their justifications for eating dairy?

Answer by BoneBrothFast for Why do primal eaters believe dairy products are ok for consumption?

2012-10-21T15:27:40Z

Because high-quality dairy is healthy. The same way that high-quality traditionally prepared (WAPF) grains are healthy.

Answer by Rea for Why do primal eaters believe dairy products are ok for consumption?

2012-10-21T15:43:09Z

Hmm, it is either healthy or not healthy depending on who you are and how your body handles it. It seems there is a lot of contradictory claims on the issue of hormones in milk affecting humans.

The way I see it dairy is loaded with nutrients, protein and vitamins, and is easy, and is delicious. Not everyone is aiming for 100 percent primal, but a feasible meal plan for daily life.

I personally am not too big on dairy. I choose occasional high fat yogurt or creme fraiche, small amounts of delicious cheese, and a dollop of organic cream for coffee one or two cups per day. (Organic cream-- oddly enough I chose it not so much because it's organic but because all the other creams have thickeners like carrageenan-- why? It's already thick.)

As well I think eating some dairy, within reason, makes giving up so many other foods more feasible, especially as a transition, and if you are feeding a household.

Answer by Liz for Why do primal eaters believe dairy products are ok for consumption?

2012-10-21T16:27:03Z

Butter and cheese from grass-fed dairy are good sources of K2.

Answer by Varelse for Why do primal eaters believe dairy products are ok for consumption?

2012-10-21T16:28:41Z

My justification is that I like it, I do well on it as I have no casein/lactose issues, the issue of hormones is definitely up for debate, and insulin secretion is not necessarily a bad thing. Just like cortisol, we need insulin. Insulin resistance is a bad thing, but I certainly don't know of anyone who has given themselves T2D from dairy sugars.

Dairy isn't for everyone, but there is no food that is right for every single person.

Answer by aseafish for Why do primal eaters believe dairy products are ok for consumption?

2012-10-21T16:29:57Z

Beats me. I know this will offend some, but often what I read and hear sounds like justification for eating what you like. I am not telling anyone not to eat dairy; I simply don't get it.

Answer by MarkES for Why do primal eaters believe dairy products are ok for consumption?

2012-10-21T17:18:53Z

It's often fatty or fermented grass-fed dairy that have no/small amounts of the problematic lactose sugars or casein proteins, like cream, butter/ghee, cheese, yogurt.

Answer by CD for Why do primal eaters believe dairy products are ok for consumption?

2012-10-21T17:32:46Z

Primal blueprint does not recommend dairy. It is, at best, in the gray area. Personally, I have 0 adverse reactions to dairy, and I have numerous positive benefits. Why wouldn't I continue to consume it?

http://www.marksdailyapple.com/dairy-intolerance/#axzz29xJwDFMp

Answer by Gary for Why do primal eaters believe dairy products are ok for consumption?

2012-10-21T17:35:28Z

It's not a question of belief, it's a question of fact and experience. Some people produce lactase in sufficient quantities to deal with lactose, so why shouldn't they eat dairy? Not a question of belief. Many might not technically produce enough but have no bad experience with dairy. Their experience therefore tells them it's OK to eat. Maybe the FACTS and EXPERIENCE of the benefits of dairy outweigh the negatives, and they aren't so dogmatic as to base what they eat on a theory rather than facts and experience.

Answer by nada for Why do primal eaters believe dairy products are ok for consumption?

2012-10-21T18:41:41Z

there's nothing wrong with it. dairy can be very good for you. excuses are not necessary

Answer by Diane for Why do primal eaters believe dairy products are ok for consumption?

2012-10-22T01:23:20Z

In reality, the diet of hunter-gatherers and the diet of pastoralists are largely the same. Many Primal Blueprint followers eat no dairy and some who do (like myself) eat only cheese or yogurt and never drink milk. I let the bacteria eat the indigestible stuff and leave me the tasty stuff. I think drinking milk is for babies and basing your diet on yogurt and smoothies is for sissies.

Answer by scottts for Why do primal eaters believe dairy products are ok for consumption?

2012-10-22T01:56:46Z

Well dairy FAT provides a great source of real vitamin A and K2 without any issues with lactose or casein.

Answer by JoshKrouse for Why do primal eaters believe dairy products are ok for consumption?

2012-10-22T02:38:52Z

I can tell you I think of myself as 100% Paleo despite eating raw organic dairy.. And by that I mean unpasteurized milk, I have yet to culture Kefir, or yogurt, but I will soon be ordering Kefir culturing grains (should be called granules because they're not anywhere like the grains your probably thinking of) soon. Until, I read, about milk, not pasteurized milk or dairy, because I avoid that stuff to no end, but real raw organic milk being unbeneficial then I'll stop drinking it.

But so far everything I've read even in paleo circles has to do with intolerances, of which I have no experience with. It seems to me that there is so little that has been studied in regards to raw milk that it needs to be further explored before it can be demonized like pasteurized milk products. I think the findings may surprise all of us in the paleosphere who as a collective whole have been known to discount all milk as being bad.

Answer by cocobean for Why do primal eaters believe dairy products are ok for consumption?

2013-02-01T20:45:13Z

A reason why there is a lot of negative talk about dairy is that many, many people are lactose intolerant. It is much more common than say nut or seafood allergies. Many, like myself, get stomach aches from milk. I can tolerate other forms of dairy with less lactose such as cheese and even cottage cheese. There are varying degrees of lactose intolerance. Some even have negative reactions to butter.

That being said, it is not ideal to base your diet around dairy. Animal meats are much better sources of you dietary needs, and they do not give nearly as many people digestive problems.

Personally, I eat the dairy that I can handle only occasionally. Sometimes I will have cottage cheese before bed on a day that I work out for its casein. Most of my protein and fat, however, come from animals.