Blog

2

what do you guys think of this? do you believe it can be beneficial at all or even for short-term use with a good diet? do you think if you take hormones long enough your body stops producing its own hormones? or do you think your body would be able to kick-in and make hormones again like before?

flag

2 Answers

1

Progesterone has certainly helped me in the last few months with perimenopausal symptoms. I'm 49.

AFAIK, bio-identical estrogen is only available by prescription and so you would have to consult your care provider about that. Saliva testing is the way to go for hormone levels.

Before going Primal (18 months ago), I used Pro-gest cream for about 6 months to help with insomnia, dryness & weight gain. Once I got my diet tweaked, I stopped using it and have been symptom-free until the last 3 months.

Now I use it to prevent spotting between periods and it has been very effective for me. I've actually had fewer chocolate cravings and less bloating in the week before my period this month.

Dr. John Lee's books have been very helpful to me and worth reading even if you are not approaching Menopause.

My understanding is that it can help the body to balance hormones, since Progesterone is a precursor for the other sex hormones.

Best to use Progesterone in physiological doses (~20 mg) day during days 5-26 of your cycle and see how you feel. Large doses (The horrible Wiley Protocol, for example.) should be avoided.

link|flag
its weird bc im young, tested low on both progesterone and estrogen. i tried taking progesterone otc and it made me VERY VERY cranky so i stopped. i take otc estrogen cream (it exists) bi-estro and my mood instantly improved. i have major bloating and chocolate cravings too. i basically feel like im going through menopause – holly Apr 16 2012 at 0:27
oh andi basically have the worst fibro ever, im only 28 – holly Apr 16 2012 at 0:31
2 
holly young perimenopausal girls need 30 day saliva studies....we talked about this at Paleo fx on a mastermind. Not all docs do them but look for one that does. Dan Kalish has a link to many docs who do this on his site. He is out of the Bay area. – The Quilt Apr 16 2012 at 0:51
1 
Progesterone will initially "turn on" estrogen receptors and I felt pretty yucky for the first couple of weeks until my balance was restored. It sounds like you need to work with an endocrinologist, get your thyroid checked and see what else is going on. – Dragonfly Apr 16 2012 at 0:51
yeah i havent had much luck because all of my labs are "in range". im saving up to go to an osteopath. i hate having to deal with health insurance. it gives me major anxiety – holly Apr 16 2012 at 20:53
show 2 more comments
1

Besides the (repetitive) Internet chatter and sensationalism can you elaborate on what you know to be bad about Wiley? Our very progressive, anti-aging dr, who is a huge supporter of all that is Paleo and Primal has presribed it to me, and 3 of my friends. (Very serious and curious about your reply-thank you!)

link|flag
1 
Caroline you may want to add a comment under Dragonfly's answer so she will get notification that someone has left a comment for her. Otherwise she may never notice your question here given as an answer to the original question. – Shari Bambino Apr 15 2012 at 23:40
1 
Looky here: wileywatch.org I have also looked into the protocol and would not touch it with a ten foot pole. Peri-menopausal & post-menopausal women taking massive amounts of progesterone (amounts that are only produced during pregnancy) makes absolutely NO sense to me. – Dragonfly Apr 16 2012 at 0:56
And I work with pregnant women, btw... – Dragonfly Apr 16 2012 at 1:18
1 
Also, my progressive, holistic doc (MD and Ayuvedic-trained) read the book and wrote a negative review on Amazon. "As a physician, I can tell you that Wiley's logic is poor, that her references to the scientific literature are often incorrect, and that she makes completely unfounded assumptions as to the safety of her method. Further, I have treated about ten women who tried the Wiley protocol through other physicians and found it, after a few months, to be worse than useless. This woman presents herself quite dangerously as a medical authority. Do not take this book seriously." – Dragonfly Apr 16 2012 at 1:42
1 
drerika.typepad.com/notepad/2006/10/… – Dragonfly Apr 16 2012 at 2:01

Your Answer

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.