I am sitting here studying for this nutrition class im taking (I know I know I was just curious about what the other side based their arguments on so I signed up)
We are reading about how we make vit d from cholesterol and sun. So us paleo folks do not fear cholesterol and eat it with abandon and then our levels go up (tons of posts on here freaking out about it). But we do NOT get enough sunlight.. so then we supplement with vit d.. we are stuck with all this cholesterol that we aren't using? Our ancestors probably needed all that extra cholesterol to make use of the days outside..
Could that be the cause of high numbers?
I know it must be way more complicated than that and there are many other factors. But what do you think?
Not likely. Most folks consuming many 100s of milligrams of cholesterol daily, but vitamin D supplementation is some 1000 times lower than that in terms of mass - 10000 IU = 250 micrograms. Cholesterol is used much more in cell structures and things like bile acids than the minute amount that goes towards vitamin D biosynthesis.
This is a nice idea, but I say no because of my personal experience. Last summer, I got more sun regularly than any time in my life. My VitD was 58.8 and my cholesterol (Trigs, VLDL, sdLDL) was going up up up and HDL going down. 4-5 times per week of full exposure to San Diego sun did not help my cholesterol. I actually attribute most of the problem to too much dairy fat (butter, ghee, cream), which I have since sharply reduced.