Blog

2

What are your views on function medicine and naturopathy? If someone were sick would you send them to a functional doctor? What type of doctor might cause more harm for a diabetic?

flag

3 Answers

2

Unmanaged diabetes would cause harm for a diabetic no matter who they went to. Some MDs are bad doctors and some naruropaths are quacks. I'd get a recommendation. Some of the MDs that I've been to in recent years were great, but then left for other places. A recent one, was not the greatest, even though an internist in a large clinic. I finally switched to a country doc in a tiny, small-town clinic and she's been tremendous. I think there is room for the naturopath and there is a reputable one nearby that I would go to. The problem is insurance and the cost. My MD sort of comes close because she does go the more natural approach when possible. Not everyone is that fortunate.

Our University hospital now has a naturopath option, so they are seeing the benefit of it. Diabetes is nothing to mess with. My daughter who is an RN student just had a case of a 30 something who had poorly managed diabetes and lots of damage that probably can't be reversed.

Some people throw up their arms and fire their doctor, go to the naturopath, and I've seen it where they don't get the medical help they need. On the other hand I was told by my neurologist to pick my weapon (medicine) as if he'd done all he could, and truthfully I don't think they did all they could. In the end I did the research and had to be my own advocate anyway. If I went to a naturopath I'd do it to complement and not replace what the MD was doing.

link|flag
1 
Your first paragraph has a great point: I've had terrible naturopaths and terrible doctors. I've also had good doctors, and am keeping my eyes open for a good naturopath! It really depends on the practitioner. – JeJ Apr 21 2012 at 22:06
1

I found 2 doctors, one is internal Medicine, and the other seems to handle IBS and thyroid stuff which sounds up my alley. Both are near places which have great bars too! This website has a lot of doctors more than suggested.

http://www.functionalmedicine.org/

link|flag
-2

I know little or nothing of Functional Medicine, but Naturopathy is 100% bunk. This link should get you started on accurate information sources: http://www.naturowatch.org/

There is a link to a paper about the man who founded Functional Medicine: http://www.quackwatch.org/04ConsumerEducation/bland.html

I am diabetic and am off meds and keeping normal blood glucose levels through diet and exercise. There are good sources for information which are neither 'quacky' nor 1-size-fits-all pill pushers. Look around.

link|flag
2 
naturopathic doctor NDs (not naturopaths) have a very science-based education. the first 2 years are very similar to what MDs study!aanmc.org/education/comparing-nd-md-curricula.php – Aglaee the Paleo RD Jul 25 at 7:37
some people are unbelievable. – Crowlover Aug 9 at 23:14
There doesn't seem to be any difference what so ever between NDs and other naturopaths, except some NDs have spend more money on getting their degrees in woo. quackwatch.com/01QuackeryRelatedTopics/… – Jon Thoroddsen Aug 9 at 23:36
If you've never been to a Functional doctor - then how do you know? Functional Medicine is NOT Quackery. It's been a life saving for me personally. – Want2BHealthyGirl Aug 9 at 23:55
How has it been life saving? – primallykosher Aug 10 at 2:38
show 1 more comment

Your Answer

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.