Blog

3

What do you think of the idea of drinking olive oil, say 400 calories' worth, at night if I'm still hungry? It's the cheapest calories I can get that seems reasonably healthy.

flag
youtube.com/watch?v=30Wr1jtDkWM – Paul Apr 26 2012 at 6:33
1 
Totally true, I mean, there are people thinking olive oil is quality nutrition here! nutritiondata.self.com/facts/… vs nutritiondata.self.com/facts/fats-and-oils/509/2 – Korion Apr 26 2012 at 9:02
3 
Whole coconuts would be good. Its not processed. – Jan Apr 26 2012 at 12:49
1 
Here's a thread on "dirt cheap paleo": paleohacks.com/questions/75069/… – tdgor Apr 26 2012 at 12:49
1 
Marrow would be great as well, certainly better than milk, and in someplaces they are free. Just find a good butcher and always buy everything from him. I get free stuff, even when i live in the country that has one of the worlds most highest prices in foods (Finland). – Jan Apr 26 2012 at 12:50
show 6 more comments

20 Answers

5

If I were you, I would have no more than one tablespoon or two. And you can add some shredded carrot. And sesame seeds. And it's a salad! Or you can add some baked/roasted sweet potatoes and parsnips. And beets.

Just don't drink too much or it. If you take it in smaller doses, I don't see why not.

link|flag
12

That sounds gross and pointless (in my opinion).

link|flag
The point is to nourish my body on the cheap. It is incumbent upon you naysayers to explain why it doesn't do that. Or at least, that's what I was hoping for. – Paleoish Dude Apr 26 2012 at 10:45
2 
I think it is fundamentally not "nourishing" to eat raw ingredients like medicine when you can put together a meal with the same ingredients. – tdgor Apr 26 2012 at 12:54
Thank god for this. When we reach the point of drinking oil, we have likely gone too far. – Kasra Apr 27 2012 at 13:54
1 
Yeah, seems like taking the notion of "food as fuel" a bit too far. – Phazo Apr 28 2012 at 20:11
8

Warm some coconut milk (aprox half a pint) mix in 20g of Kerrygold, 3 tsp of cocoa, a pinch of cinnamon then half a pot of double cream (aprox 50ml) and continue to warm on a low heat for ten mins. Thats just over 400kcals, tastes delicious has a high sat fat ratio and is great for testosterone boosting if taken around 10pm enhancing night time recovery. Not recommended if you are SAD.

link|flag
3

I actually do this to suppress appetite - definitely works.

The theory is from Seth Roberts: http://blog.sethroberts.net/

link|flag
1 
I did that a long time ago, but it stopped working for me. When it worked, it was amazing though. – Paleoish Dude Apr 26 2012 at 10:47
I have also done it with no lasting negative effects besides people being squicked at me drinking oil. I switched to fish oil capsules for the cardiac bonus but other than having to slowly ramp up so that you don't have too much digestive disturbance I can't think of any issues. – Vrimj Apr 26 2012 at 14:21
3

I just don't know if you'd actually be able to do it very often, doesn't sound palatable. I'd definitely try adding a TB here and there and definitely consider coconut milk, coconut cream additions if you can....I think you'll get more enjoyment and maybe even stomach it.

Even if you went so far as to indulge yourself with a mix of ghee, coconut cream, honey and coconut, toss in a bit of organic cocoa and roll in nuts....you'd probably stomach it better (yes, this is a cheat indulgent I use but in moderation since its really high fat)

link|flag
3

I did this for about two months without any issues. I drank 2-3 tbsp morning and night. I was doing it to help gain weight and to try to relieve constipation. It didn't help me gain much weight, but it sure did make me poop and also made my farts smell horrendous.

link|flag
3

If it's cheap, it ain't 100% virgin olive oil. High quality coconut oil is much less expensive than high quality olive oil.

link|flag
2 
73% of olive oil sold in the US is not pure. You couldn't pay me to use olive oil to increase calories. As others suggested, use coconut oil if you're going to do this. slashfood.com/2011/04/14/… – invisible ink Apr 29 2012 at 13:46
2

I don't see the point in drinking 400 calories worth of olive oil. I feel like their are less disgusting ways of satisfying a craving at night without spending much money.

link|flag
I am happy to amuse everyone. – Paleoish Dude Apr 26 2012 at 6:44
Have to say I don't find it disgusting at all. It's about 40-50 ml. Maybe certain people have a distaste for it, like sardines/liver. – begob Apr 28 2012 at 14:31
2

What do I think? I think it sounds pretty grim. It sounds like a recipe for deliberately minimizing the amount of pleasure you derive from your food. Why do that (yeah, food reward theory, yada yada, but you didn't say you were trying to lose weight)?

Have bigger meals during the day. Yeah, I get that you're poor. But you'd be better off, assuming that you have a source of cheap high quality 100% virgin olive oil, incorporating those same 400 calories into your current diet throughout the day. It would be so much kinder to yourself. Have a salad! Roast some vegetables! Make pesto!

I have no idea what's available at food banks these days. If it's not all macaroni and cheese and Twinkies, maybe you can find food there. A longer-term fix might be growing some of your own vegetables.

I understand the concept of thinking of food as fuel not entertainment, but this seems excessive.

EDIT: What about eggs? Saute two eggs in that olive oil. You can frequently get eggs for, what, 99 cents/dozen? Two eggs is about 150 calories for sixteen cents.

link|flag
1 
Yeah. I eat a lot of eggs. They are pretty cheap as well. Coconut milk is cheaper than meat but not as cheap as eggs. Olive oil is way cheaper than eggs. I think I'll just put it over some shredded cabbage or something. Thanks for your input. – Paleoish Dude Apr 26 2012 at 23:12
1 
And I don't believe in the food reward theory. I'm in the Gary Taubes camp. – Paleoish Dude Apr 26 2012 at 23:19
2

I drink olive oil and have for several years (even prior to paleo) not only did I note an amazing cognitive response, but my skin (although it has never been an issue)saw tremendous benefits as well. the true benefit, especially for someone focusing on fitness through paleo is satiety with fats begins in the mouth unlike protein (gut) and the leptins (sp) quickly shuts of 'your' feed me desires-- this will allow you to make wiser food choices at the pantry.

Side Note** Several years ago, the oldest woman in the world (I believe 128??) who was Israeli, explained that she believed her secret to health and longevity was a result of her olive oil consumption. Apparently, for the past 40 years or so, she consumed roughly 6oz a day from a tumbler.

link|flag
How much do you drink? Do you chase it with water? Do you avoid other flavors for an hour after like Seth Roberts recommends? Do you use extra light olive oil? – Paleoish Dude May 1 2012 at 2:45
1

Why would you want to do that? It's the equivalent of eating 30 bananas a day...and we all know how that pans out...

link|flag
How is it the equivalent? There are no carbs in olive oil. – Paleoish Dude Apr 26 2012 at 5:58
Let me spell it out for you: I'm poor. :) – Paleoish Dude Apr 26 2012 at 6:00
2 
exactly lol, 30 bananas a day sounds even saner to me at this point; drinking Olive Oil is insane – Paul Apr 26 2012 at 6:32
30 bananas is 3000 calories. – Warren D Apr 26 2012 at 17:35
1 
It's not equivalent in the sense of macronutrients, that's not what I meant. But seeing as how this is a Paleo community, would consuming 30 bananas or 30 tablespoons of Olive Oil be Paleo? Probably Not. When would a Caveman ever come across that much of either in the wild? Plus, as much as no one here wants to admit it. Olive Oil is cultivated, it's not "exactly" paleo in the sense that I can walk outside and find it on a tree. (Yes, we can find olives, but how many olives go into a tablespoon of olive oil). I'm not saying to not consume olive oil at all, just be reasonable. – Forgotten18 Apr 28 2012 at 20:42
1

How about cottage cheese?

link|flag
Good idea, but it's not readily available in Japan, where I live, and probably not cheap when available. – Paleoish Dude Apr 26 2012 at 23:20
1

Robb Wolf did this for a while, check his podcasts. He stopped doing it though.

link|flag
That's where I got the idea. Robb Wolf had a blog entry where he said if he were broke, he would just eat a lot of coconut oil. But in Japan, where I live, coconut oil isn't really any cheaper than meat. Olive oil, however, is much cheaper. – Paleoish Dude Apr 26 2012 at 23:09
1

If you're going to go our for a hard night drinking. Have a shot of olive oil, the Mediterranean's would take a spoonful to coat their stomachs before going out to prevent a hangover.

link|flag
1

If you're going to do this make sure you have your omega ratios in check. Not a biggie if you're eating correctly on the whole, but consuming a dose of olive oil could push your over the n6 range.

Why not go for some macadamia or walnuts? Probably not as cheap (not sure if you meant that literally or metaphorically?) as olive oil, but at least you'd get some n3 in there, too.

If you're sweating the carbs, maybe opt for some omega-3 fish oil as a substitute.

link|flag
1

Yeah, I've done that before. You can just pour it directly into your mouth from the spout, otherwise you'll waste 1/4 of it coating the glass you drink out of.

Alternatively, mix it with a few scoops of psyllium husk powder, a couple tablespoons of full fat cottage cheese, water, stir it up quick and chug it down. It's gross but will immediately kill any hunger pangs.

Just an FYI, though, chugging olive oil promotes a gag reflex even with expensive virgin olive oil, and you will probably have some GI issues if you do it on more than an intermittent basis.

link|flag
1

My mom worked for a guy who would drink a bottle of olive oil with his lunch every day, seriously. Apparently he was skinny as a rail somehow.

link|flag
0

I'm not sure why there's such a backlash here. I agree that there are tastier and more pleasurable ways to get in some extra calories than tons and tons of olive oil, but Paleoish Dude said he was thinking maybe "400 calories worth." That would be approximately 4 Tbsp, right? (Give or take for the calorie/portion geeks out there.) I wouldn't call that drinking olive oil. Some people here swear by the Bulletproof coffee with butter in it, others drop a Tbsp of coconut oil into their coffee or tea. Purposely adding fat doesn't seem so alien around here. (Depending on one's needs and goals, of course of course.)

Again, I'm not saying 4 Tbsp of olive oil is the best thing to do every single day, but many of us have probably done a lot wackier things here and there, no?

(I do have to agree, though, that if you did this often, you'd be going through a lot of oil and that would defeat the purpose of looking for something cheap, assuming you would use a GOOD olive oil.)

link|flag
0

-make mayonaise from olive oil and dip every veggy in it.

-eat/use everything from a bird. make broth from bones, if you know how to cook you can even eat the bones because there so soft.

-cabbage, cabbage and onions.

-look outside for eatable lettuce ,seeds etc.

link|flag
0

I guess it wold be OK if you could be SURE it was real olive oil. Seems to me the only stuff you can be sure about is way too expensive to just be drinking every morning. I'd go for coconut oil or ghee instead and use rendered animal fats and butter for cooking. I buy olive oil but I use it sparingly on my salads. It would really suck if you were unwittingly guzzling canola oil or something. Might be reversing all the good you are doing on your paleo diet.

http://www.foodrenegade.com/your-extravirgin-olive-oil-fake/

link|flag
I know...isn't it depressing? I wonder if we can trust ANY frikkin' labels in the U.S. anymore. (Which is why it's best to stick with foods that don't have labels, like straight up fresh meat & veg, but you would like to think olive oil is olive oil. The fact that that is not the case shows how far off the map we are at this point.) Grrr! – Amy B. Jul 2 at 18:25

Your Answer

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.