Blog

4

1

Is Beer Paleo/Primal, I've been living Primal for 1 year now, i haven't been drinking the stuff. Can Beer be considered a healthy carb? I'm dying to go out and buy a six pack of good ones.

Cheers.

flag
7 
It's a vice that contributes enough to social and psychological health that I make an exception for it. – foreveryoung Jul 1 at 18:43
1 
Assuming you're not a celiac, you'll probably tolerate a beer or 6. :) – Matt Jul 1 at 18:44
1 
Just go and buy them. No, it is not Paleo but if you really miss it - go ahead and drink. Then come back and post - did it taste as you thought it would? Being Primal for so long will alter your taste for neolithic foods. – VB Jul 1 at 19:32
They did taste delicious! I got a six pack of Red Stripes, it was a nice break from Scotch and Red Wine. – Alvaro Jul 2 at 17:06

7 Answers

7

Is beer paleo, primal, or a healthy carb? Probably not.

But really, do you need to justify having a beer once in a while? I say go enjoy a cold one, life's too short.

link|flag
1 
Maybe life is too short because too many people are 'enjoying a cold one' too often. :P – Forest Jul 2 at 4:18
7

I think it might be. If I drink enough of it I start to act like a caveman. Does that count?

link|flag
It would be funny, if it did not have gluten and if he is celiac or gluten sensitive - he will remember this night for the rest of his life. – VB Jul 1 at 19:33
3 
i still think it's funny! – Rebekah Jul 1 at 20:25
5

No, it's not primal or paleo. That being said, there ARE gluten-free beers out there that aren't terrible, as well as ciders and wines that are quite tasty.

link|flag
I love you. Thanks for the answer! People, could you please upvote this? – VB Jul 1 at 19:33
the gf beers are... ok at best, but when you just gotta sip one at dinner, it's nice to have it! +1 – Rebekah Jul 1 at 20:26
+1 for cider. Better than beer any day in my book and gluten free. – Crowlover Jul 1 at 21:47
The downside of cider is the typically high sugar content. But tasty, yes. :) – WyldKard Jul 2 at 22:19
I enjoy a good Granny Smith Cider as an occasional treat on a hot summer day :D Also, thank you VB :) – Miriam Jul 3 at 2:54
4

Let's see, they're made from grains. Specifically wheat and barley. They contain protein, sometimes as much as 2 grams or more. You know what the main type of protein they contain in particular? Gluten. Finally, unless you're drinking bud light platinum or some other very light and purified beer, they contain liquefied starch, again from grains, that surely has a more destructive effect on metabolism than even eating the cereal grains to begin with. Oh, and don't forget about the phytoestrogens from the hops and whatnot.

Moral of the story: I drink red wine. It's becoming increasingly acceptable for masculine men to opt for red wine. You don't even need to go into the above paleo rant...just say you prefer it, or if that doesn't fly, mention carbs/health and people tend to let it slide. Only on the rare occasion when your're tailgating for a game or somewhere else where wine isn't an option can you be forced to consume beer. And on those occasions, it's usually something like bud light platinum for me.

link|flag
1 
+1 for all the gluten references. – VB Jul 1 at 19:34
1 
My question wasn't about caring about what people think or say, i don't have a problem with drinking wine, i do it all the time – Alvaro Jul 1 at 21:04
YAYYYYYYYYY red wine!! – Crowlover Jul 1 at 21:49
3 
I am so confused why this has gotten so many up votes. You point out that beer has phytoestrogens, and yet so does red wine- resveratrol being the most famed one of them all.ALso, you say that ordering red wine is "becoming increasingly acceptable for masculine men." Seriously? WHen and where was it unacceptable for "masculine men" to order red wine?Are you implying that only gay guys used to order red wine?Where I come from drinking red wine is encouraged.WHITE wine is often considered more feminine of a drink, not red.I order white all the time if the occasion calls for it. I don't care. – foreveryoung Jul 1 at 22:39
1 
Don't agree with the hating on starch. – Matt Jul 1 at 23:06
show 1 more comment
4

Beer is the only non-whole9 compliant thing I consume. I am VLC and very strict paleo, but once in a while, I just have to let loose. I went to a backyard wedding yesterday, it was very hot, my husband doesn't drink, and I was in the mood, so I brought a 6 pk of PBR pounders. It was amazing, it killed my craving for beer for a while, and it will probably be another 6-8 months before I do it again.

link|flag
6 
I forgot to add that since going paleo, I have become a very cheap date... – Divrgurl13 Jul 1 at 19:36
it evens out the steak and sashimi we order :) – Rebekah Jul 1 at 20:26
2

I work in the brew industry and drink beer as its part of my livelihood, I also homebrew cider. When out at events or tastings I just keep to small amounts, 4-6oz. pours, sometimes 2oz as it allows me to try more offerings. Alcohol in general does not impede my goals - I also have no allergies and what few sensitivities I have I am aware of, so I abstain from items that may affect that. As others have said - enjoy yourself, life is too short. If I can offer any advice go to a bar that has outstanding choices and ask for a half pour and have a glass of water in-between. You can always have more :) Cheers!

A great thread on ciders

My notes on GF beer:

There are many choices but unfortunately not are widely available. Yet. Kettlehouse Brewing and Strange Brewing had GF offerings at the American Beer Festival but sadly that was the only place to attain it. Grr! I've also had odds and ends through the Midwest, South and Northeast but they fall into the same categories as Kettlehouse and Strange - can't get 'em or they're one-off's at brewpubs.

If you live in the Portland Oregon area, Deschutes has a GF beer on tap only and it changes on occasion. Hands down this brewer, for all their brews, is outstanding. In addition, and it's slowly trickling out of Oregon and into other states is Omission. It's by Widmer and seriously solid. Outside of the seasonal T'weasonale by Dogfish Head they are the top choices. Another delicious one is by Joseph James but it, like the Omission, is a bit more challenging to find based on your region.

Most definitely widely-available: Red Bridge, New Grist, Bards, Green's, New Planet, St. Peters, Brasserie de Brunehaut, Estrella.

link|flag
1

Omission is a very solid gluten free beer.

link|flag

Your Answer

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.