Okay, I am not freaking out over this at all, its more a matter of curiosity.
When I ate very poorly, super high carb, very little fat or meat except junk food, my LDL was overly high, and my HDL "normal".
Now ive been on paleo whole foods, low carb, higher fat (fatty cuts, butter, hard cheese, coconut oil, more meat) for a few months and my LDL is coming back pretty low, and well below so called "risk range" and my HDL has dropped into "risk range". According to the standard line, which I know is questionable, if my HDL was higher, id be "very healthy" lipid wise my doctor said. (She suggested fish oil). 6 months back my doctors were starting to tentitively mention statins cos of my LDL (no I would never, lol)
Now I was under the impression that sat fats raised both of those, not lowered them both. Is this genetic or why would both my LDL and HDL go down on LC paleo?
As time goes on, I'm becoming less and less convinced of the LC way of living. If it makes you feel better overall, fantastic! But I've been reading and hearing too many stories in the AE (ancestral eating) community that support negative effects of LC. A suggestion is you may want to try tinkering with going moderate carb, retest in a month or so, and see where your results fall then.
You may also want to consider that the body often reacts in a weighted scale like manner in achieving homeostasis. What I mean by this, is that your body is not going to immediately go, "Oh! They're eating better, let's shift everything in the right direction!" Sometimes our good results wax and wane along with our bad results. If your LDL is pattern A, I believe ("fluffy") there's not much of a cause for concern in that department anyways. Fish oil is kind of a toss up on the effectiveness at promoting HDL. I've read articles that say it does, and articles that say it more effectively targets triglycerides and blood pressure issues.
There's also the issue with quantity over frequency. A lot of people on here talk about consuming all of the right foods, but it's far more complicated than that--namely, how much are you consuming?
True Indication of the benefits of Paleo 2 Answers
Total CHOL count up on Paleo 2 Answers