Blog

1

SOme people seem to do well on very low carb but some seem to require higher carb intake in order to feel better. For those of you who have experimented, what daily carb levels do you seem to do best at? What are your upper and lower thresholds for carb intake and why do you think that is?

Edited to add: Please give approx gram intake numbers if you happen to know em.

flag

15 Answers

2

Check out The Primal Blueprint Carbohydrate Curve at http://www.marksdailyapple.com/how-to-succeed-with-the-primal-blueprint/ Mark Sisson offers an excellent guideline here! Please note that this can vary with amount of activity.

link|flag
5

I more or less zero-carbed for ages (e.g. whatever carbs I got from spinach, the odd bit of cruciferous veg, coconut and balsamic vinegar: easily less than 15g per day). I've been convinced by Optimal Diet reasoning (or more precisely, by Peter) that it's healthiest to eat enough carbs to not be in deep ketosis all the time (~40g for me according to the OD), so as to reduce cortisol and gluconeogenesis, for a while, but in practise had never gotten around to eating that much daily. Eating 40g of carbs on just vegetables is rather trying and whenever I did eat that many carbs I just felt worse (sleepy, slightly bloated etc).

Eventually I got round to matching my practise to my theory however and made a concerted effort to eat up to ~40g via 1 small sweet potato per day. Still, I seem to feel better when I am very low carbing, (with the proviso that I begin to feel worse- slow and sluggish and aching joints and no ability to do intense exercise- after a very extended period of low carbing), so I'm now just intermittently eating about the same amount of carb, which seems to keep me from the long-term slow-down of low carbing while allowing me to not be eating carbs most of the time.

One of my prime motivations for increasing carb intake is because I've recently (last 1.5-2 years) been experiencing problems staying asleep- namely waking up far too early, at approx 4am without having slept enough and without being able to get back to sleep (particularly ironic given my prior sleep problems!). At least one other person I've come across has experienced this and connected it with carb intake and others have suggested that some intake of carb is necessary for optimum serotonin production (incidentally, another motivation for increasing carbs was to increase testosterone) and stop occasional rushes of cortisol, so whenever I do have a serving of carbs it's in the evening, shortly before bed.

Naturally I also focus my carb-intake around workout days so as to benefit from relative muscle insulin sensitivity and aid recovery.

link|flag
2

About 250 grams of carbs per day, mostly from starch.

link|flag
2

What very much works for me is having absolutely no idea. I've never counted a calorie, carb, or gram of anything I eat. After nine months paleo I'm in better shape than I've been for the last 10 years.

For me, counting would ruin a lot of the easy / natural appeal of paleo.

link|flag
Personally, eat what I feel like eating within the paleo food options. However, once in a while, I'll plug in a day's intake into fitday to see my approx numbers and nutrient intake. I don't count this is 'counting' carbs exactly though. I do it mostly to keep an eye on nutrient intake, but the macronutrient numbers that fitday calculates are also of interest to my curiosity from a scientific perspective. – Eva Nov 9 2010 at 21:25
2

20-150 grams a day :)

link|flag
2

My sweet spot is between 100/150 per day.

link|flag
about the same for me. – No more. Nov 9 2010 at 22:57
2

200+ on training days.

about 100 on an average day.

link|flag
1

Children and Pregnant women probably do better with a more moderately high level of carbos

I strongly suspect that those with Mesopotamian ancestry have evolved greater tolerance.

link|flag
What do you consider a moderately high level? – Eva Nov 9 2010 at 18:08
A couple of slices of bread a day, preferably sprouted or sourdough, or rye, but not necessarily It should always be "on the side" A few pieces of fruit a day -- OK. In my book, fruit for kids almost unlimited. If you try to stop them, it'll backfire into pure candy – zohar Nov 11 2010 at 8:56
1

I've been zero carb for 2 months now. I had to taper down for a few months but here I am. Whoohoo what an energy boost.

link|flag
1

I've found I perform well athletically at zero carb or at cyclic recovery carbs very heavy post workout. Day to day carbs outside of exercise weren't as positive an experience.

Zero carb felt great but requires Alot of planning.

Cycling carbups allow me to enjoy social situations and sushi, I just workout real heavy beforehand.

When I vary from this, I notice variations in both energy and mood that I don't like

link|flag
do you eat carbs all day pwo, or just load up immediately pwo and then eat low carb the rest of your meals that day? – animaleater Jun 19 at 8:54
1

How many: Usually under 20 for me. Rarely fewer than 10 or more than 25.

Why these numbers: Too few has an "undernourished/something's missing or out of balance" pattern, and too many causes the standardly reported carb symptoms.

link|flag
1

i personally don't measure (=too much fuss), i'm just trying to cycle and not to mix them with fat (especially, starch with fat)

link|flag
1

Anywhere from 10 to 120. 10 would be if I'm fasting though, so usually between 80-120.

link|flag
1

Chalk me up for around 100g.

link|flag
1

80-150 but none of it is starch. I dont even do sweet potatoes/yams. I just do salads.

Im a couple weeks into a new workout regime though and im def thinking about adding in sweet potatos if i dont see the increases in output that im looking for.

link|flag
1 
150g from salads? How many salads does that take? – mari Nov 10 2010 at 0:47
yeah that seems highly improbable – JeezLoise Apr 24 2012 at 2:09

Your Answer

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.