Blog

3

My mom knew I've been using coconut oil, so she spotted this stuff at Super Walmart and bought it for me.

http://www.louana.com/product-detail.aspx?productID=75&catID=44&pcatID=37

I have been using fancy extra virgin organic stuff from the health food store. Is there anything I can use this for? Or is it just bad news?

flag

10 Answers

12

You can always use it as a moisturizer for your skin and a deep conditioner for your hair, if nothing else!

link|flag
1 
I haven't got quite that deep into my coconut oil yet. I keep thinking about it though. – sherpamelissa Jan 24 2011 at 15:22
1 
coconut oil on the hair overnight makes for very soft shiny hair! – texasleah Jan 24 2011 at 16:20
3 
Let me tell you, ladies: working out hard, dry brushing, taking a shower, and then coating yourself in a thin layer of coconut oil is my elixir of youth/happiness/love. – gone2croatan Jan 24 2011 at 16:22
What is dry brushing? – sherpamelissa Jan 24 2011 at 16:50
Dry brushing: naturalhealthtechniques.com/healingtechniques/… I don't buy into all of the claims, but it has definitely made my skin look better. – gone2croatan Jan 24 2011 at 17:24
show 6 more comments
4

I used that brand from Walmart once and I don't see what's wrong with it. I used it for cooking and also ate it straight.

link|flag
That would be sweet! It just seemed too good to be true, it is 1/4 of the price of the stuff I usually buy. – sherpamelissa Jan 24 2011 at 15:21
1 
@Melissa Premium brands mark up their prices because they have a premium name and reputation. If the ingredients list is good and you can't tell the difference then you're probably okay. As much as I dislike WM it doesn't mean their products are all bad. – ScottMGS Jan 24 2011 at 16:31
The ingredients just say "Coconut Oil". LOL. I wasn't sure if how it was processed mattered and I didn't really now how to figure that one out. – sherpamelissa Jan 24 2011 at 16:49
1 
The regular Lou Ana is RBD coconut oil (I did the same research a couple years ago). It is processed to remove most unsaturated fats and free fatty acids, which is part of why it has such an incredible shelf-life. However, it is sometimes "fully hydrogenated" to deal with any stray unsaturated fatty acids. The Lou Ana people assured me that the incidental trans fatty acids produced by this process were at virtually undetectable levels - take from that what you will. I think it's mostly harmless, but I can afford the tasty "cold" pressed, so why not. – Jayan Jan 24 2011 at 22:00
Thanks Jay! This was FREE though, so I will use it. Then buy the fancy stuff again next time. – sherpamelissa Jan 25 2011 at 0:06
3

That tropical traditions page has some good info, exlaining how expeller pressed stuff is good. Expeller pressed coconut oil also has less odour and taste but some.

This page explains it's still okay: http://180degreehealth.com/2010/11/refined-coconut-oil Due to the stability of the oil it isn't much damaged in processing.

Also, the Tropical Traditions page itself states that they found more antioxidants in coconut oil processed with heat than not. Apparently a traditional way of making it (which they do not use) was to boil coconut milk until the oil separated.

RBD coconut oil is made from copra which has mould and bacteria. The processing can involve heat, and then due to the mould and bacteria it has to go through filtering with solvents. But this isn't necessarily bad again. That's explained here: http://www.coconut-oil-central.com/rbd-coconut-oil.html under the title 'Still Healthy.'

Fractionated coconut oil apparently has a longer shelf life than other coconut oil. I can't comment on residue from solvents, but if it were damaged by heat in processing it should go rancid, rather than be the most stable of oils. Also, having no taste or odour, it can be convenient for some uses. Fractionated is when they get RBD and separate the oil without solvents, leaving only medium chain fatty acids. Medium chain are better for you, and the oil is liquid at room temperature, very thin. It is used as a massage oil.

link|flag
2

i was also using an expensive brand that cost 3-4x as much. then my brother's girlfriend brought over the wm brand and honestly, i can't tell the difference between the two. maybe somebody more suited than me can answer if it's so biochemically different from the extra virgin organic stuff that it doesn't have the same effects but if it's not, i'll be using this stuff...

link|flag
1 
As far as the actual lipids go? Not really. It might have an even higher saturated fat content than the "extra virgin" stuff, because unsaturated fatty acids are processed out or "fully hydrogenated", but other than that the actual fats are pretty much the same. – Jayan Jan 24 2011 at 22:04
1

Cheap coconut oil is usually refined/chemically treated/bleached from the really crappy coconut left overs.

Tropical Traditions lists out the common ways Coconut Oil is made on this page:

http://www.tropicaltraditions.com/what_is_virgin_coconut_oil.htm

link|flag
Well, that's what I figured, but is it bad for me? Or just not as tasty? – sherpamelissa Jan 24 2011 at 16:51
I'm pretty sure there's zero research on that. :) Which means it's a personal decision. Read through how it's made, and decide whether or not you really want to be eating that kind of material. – James Jan 24 2011 at 19:53
Compares virgin and dry process coconut oil (in rats). ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/19767885 Just FYI, it's from Kerala, a big coconut producing region. – Jayan Jan 24 2011 at 22:40
1 
I do not think it is "bad" for you. It should say hydrogenated if it has been and it does NOT say that. It may not be top quality from mature coconuts but I am sure it is okay although possibly not quite as beneficial. – jo60 May 17 2012 at 15:57
1

Try to use it as a deep skin moisturizer and for oil pulling

link|flag
1

This is an interesting dispute, and for a while I was totally down with the raw/virgin/ everything in the most natural state possible, but I think may be allergic to coconut oil, and the prime culprit isn't the fat, but certain proteins that are in the expensive virgin stuff, not in the cheap processed stuff. I used that brand before and it's okay to eat it. It doesn't taste as strongly of coconut so you may be able to fry with it in situations where you would find the expensive stuff too overpowering.

link|flag
There is a differnce between "refined" and "cheap processed".I pay just as much for refined with no coconut scent as I would for Virgin. It is expeller expressed etc. Have not been able to get Virgin lately. and you re right it would be the proteins and not the fat you would be allergic too. Even people with peanut allergies are allergic to the proteins and can consume peanut oil as long as there are no proteins in it. – jo60 May 17 2012 at 20:15
0

In a moment of excessive broke-ness, I bought this stuff too. One of the main differences I've noticed is the stuff melts a lot quicker. If I leave my A/C on 80 during the day (summer in Texas), it's completely melted by the time I come home. This doesn't happen with the more expensive stuff.

So several times the stuff has been melted and hardened. Not sure if this has any negative effect on it.

As for taste, I haven't noticed any difference really.

link|flag
More evidence that it is purer- the fat is what solidifies or liquifies based on the temperature. – August May 17 2012 at 19:10
0

Burn it in an oil lamp.

link|flag
0

As a nurse, I can tell you that you are correct about the protein that you are most likely allergic to. Allergies are almost exclusively caused by proteins. I saw solid coconut oil being sold in a bulk box of 35lbs for like $45 at The Web Restaurant Store for use with popcorn. They had both solid and solid white. But even with googling it, I couldn't find out whether you could use it for other cooking. Is there a difference with this type of coconut oil that makes it only for popcorn? It's a great price, otherwise.

link|flag

Your Answer

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.