Blog

9

2

Perhaps, my google skills fail me but I can't find an average for how much K2 is in grass-fed butter. Anyone know?

EDIT: If K2 levels are as low as they seem, is supplementation a good idea?

flag

6 Answers

7

I knew I'd stumbled across information regarding the K2 content of foods somewhere in Stephen's blog. A good 30 minutes of digging and I've finally found it. See the link for a more readable format of the listed values or better yet, head to the linked (below) german database:

http://wholehealthsource.blogspot.com/2008/06/vitamin-k2-menatetrenone-mk-4.html

In the comments, Lee said...

"Stephen

I have been looking at the German food database, which is available in English. It is interesting since it gives values for amounts of vitamin K in a wide range of animal products.

Here is my summary of the amounts. The amounts are cals in 100g, mcg K in 100g and mcg K2 in 2000 calories of the food. Hope it makes sense.

Food 100g cal K2 K2 in 2000kcal

egg (raw)

chicken 154 48 623

duck 183 45 492

goose 179 45 503

yolk 348 147 845

cooked liver

pork 123 61 992

beef 147 81 1102

chicken 147 87 1184

veal 146 97 1329

liver pate 299 49 328

Dairy

C'bert/brie 362 35 193

cream 40% 373 40 214

milk,boiled 65 4 123

hard cheese 356 25 140

proces'd cheese 327 30 183

sour cream 10% 117 10 171

Edam 45% 354 30 169

butter 741 60 162

Meat

Corned beef 141 20 284

Salami 365 14 77

pork belly 469 8 34

beef rib 146 13 178

Ox tail 221 15 136

Other fats, offal, seafood and most meats contain none.

Lee April 30, 2009 9:25 AM"

end quoted material

link|flag
3 
Unfortunately you did not remember the conversation that followed where it was revealed that that list is actually for total K values, not K2. Stephan: "Lee, I believe part of the vitamin K will be K1 in most if not all of those foods." – Melmoth the Wanderer Mar 21 2011 at 13:11
5

I think you're not going to find the answer very satisfactory, but the truth is there is NOT a typical quantity of K2 in butter. It varies tremendously based on diet and soil conditions:

from Chris Masterjohn: "After analyzing over 20,000 samples of butter sent to him from around the world, however, Price found that the [vitamin K2] concentration varied 50-fold..."

FWIW, at the end of that article there is a table, with citations, listing the type and source of K2 in various foods. It shows butter as 15 mcg/100g.

link|flag
4

Butter oil is what i use when I am trying to reverse vascular calicifications and or improve osteopenia or porosis. We did do some testing on Kerry Gold butter ourselves and got real different values from the lots we bought. So I am not a big fan of theirs as I once was. Now we advocate Organic Valley who has been consistent

link|flag
How are you testing the butter for its vitamin K2 content? – Matt Mar 6 2011 at 16:16
I send sample monthly out for testing. Been doing it for three yrs to get a real feel for the foods and companies I advocate for to my patients. Eating well costs so I think testing matters. I think the more you see me post the more you realize I believe in feedback testing when eating paleo......once your fit then I think KGH is correct that one can just live. But getting there is in the details and that is where I totally disagree with him. If you want optimal you need to test. If you want better than most......dont test. – The Quilt Mar 6 2011 at 16:39
What would you say is the average level of vitamin K2 you are finding in the butter you test? In mcg per 100 grams of butter. I would be interested to know. – Matt Mar 6 2011 at 17:18
2 
Kerry Gold had some batches with zero.....infact quite a few. Organic valley goes avgs close to 7mgs per half a lb. – The Quilt Mar 21 2011 at 4:57
Dr K, a 1/2 lb of butter is about 225 grams. Assuming you meant 7 micrograms, and not 7 milligrams, that is about an average of 3mcg/100g -- not very impressive. – PortlandAllan Mar 21 2011 at 5:44
show 2 more comments
3

It's not a nutrient that the food companies really track. It probably varies depending on the time of year--I would expect to see more of it in the spring and far less in the fall and winter.

link|flag
i found that about 6% rda is contained in a tablespoon of conventional butter. Surely someone, somewhere has a number. – No more. Mar 6 2011 at 5:55
2

Conventional butter in Japan has 21 mcg/100g. (Kamao 2007)

K2 levels for seemingly all other foods EXCEPT butter are given in this article

If K2 levels have indeed been measured in grass-fed butter, I might be able to find out, as the above lab is down the street from my office!

link|flag
isn't it crazy that it's not easy to get a level even though it's thrown around all the time as a great K2 source... – No more. Mar 6 2011 at 7:03
Chicken nuggets one of the best sources?! Well I never... – David Moss Mar 23 2011 at 20:28
1

This article appears to have your answer, although I can only access the abstract. I suspect the butter they test may be grass-fed, because of the nordic location. The couple studies that mentioned butter (which may be pastured or not) indicated low menaquinone levels, orders of magnitude below that of aged cheese.

http://pubs.acs.org/doi/abs/10.1021/jf000638u

link|flag
Also, this dissertation looks informative, but does not answer the question...doria.fi/bitstream/handle/10024/3268/… – Kamal Mar 21 2011 at 6:28
Nope, no values for butter. For dairy products they find 1-10 ug/100g MK-4 for dairy products, where whole milk averages 1 and cheddar cheese averages 10. – Meaty Mar 17 at 18:56

Your Answer

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.