Blog

2

Over the holidays last year, I went to the emergency room with an extremely painful gall bladder attack. When I sought solutions, the first item that came up was the Paleo Diet. Having had such pain, it was easy to go cold turkey on the diet, and even easier because the diet didn't make me crave the foods that elicit my gall bladder symptoms. Within several days, my symptoms were gone. And, I've only had a minor sense that my gall bladder was acting up about 3 weeks ago, but no real symptoms.

I didn't tell my doctor about my diet because I thought he'd crack up. I asked his nurse if it was OK to delay the surgery appointment in lieu of my dietary changes and 10 pound weight loss (at the time). Both the nurse and the doctor never heard of a gall bladder being healed. And I have yet to find anywhere, except for the flushing programs of which I am skeptical, that says a gall bladder can be healed. Like Robb says, the medical community's only real answer is to take out the offending organ. I'll have a follow-up appointment early this Summer and maybe my doctor will become a Paleo believer.

Does anyone else have a similar experience?

flag

5 Answers

6

Your gall bladder can indeed be healed. That's ridiculous that your doc told you it can't and that your only option is to take out 'the offending organ'. How about... change the offending diet that people regularly feed that organ. The organ is there for a reason. It's supposed to be there. The gallbladder controls/regulates the bile secretion for digestive purposes, especially for fats. When you eat a fatty meal (which should be pretty much every meal), your gallbladder will secrete the bile. If you have had your GB removed, you will still make bile, but since it will be unregulated, you will probably experience bile dumping and/or the opposite, where you don't have enough bile to correctly digest the fats. My mother-in-law had hers removed and now has sourced me to research this for her. What I found out about the "GB removal world" was extraordinarily frustrating. It's a HUGE industry. Something like 500,000 removals per year.

Now, please don't take offense. I'm sure there's a fair amount of folks on PH that have had theirs removed and are coping accordingly. I mean no disrespect, I promise. It's not your fault. Just like it wasn't my fault that my parents used to let me drink a case of Dr Pepper every day when I was 12. I just didn't know.

But for those who have not yet made the choice to get it removed, KEEP IT! Heal it. Only if a person is past the point of possible healing and there is no way to simply remove the stones causing severe pain would I consider the idea of removal.

If someone who is reading this is considering GB removal, and my answer here helps just one person reconsider, then fantastic. We need to eat fat. Fat is good. The gallbladder helps us digest fat. This is the ENTIRE BASIS of why conventional medicine is so quick to support the idea of removal. "You don't need it. You ARE eating a low-fat diet, right?"

Amazing, isn't it. When will people learn to connect the dots?

AndyH - glad to hear about your GB issue reversal when you switched to Paleo.

cheers!

link|flag
Thanks for the affirmation Jack. We need to spread the word, especially to the medical community. Like Robb says, the proof is in the pudding. Go on the diet and then show your doctor what it did. I can't wait to see my blood work in a couple months. – AndyH Mar 8 2011 at 16:24
3

Gall bladder removal surgery should be your very last option. Do not do it without at least trying alternatives. It may take time to dissolve the stones in the gall bladder, but there are options like lithotripsy (breaking the stones using ultrasound) or specific drugs (ursodiol or chenodiol) intended to help to dissolve the stones and even an injection of MTBE into the gallbladder to dissolve the stones.

link|flag
1 
Doctors don't want to do these things, because they are, for the most part, convinced the stones will come back. Most doctors I have seen absolutely don't believe the GB can be healed. If stones are your problem (and good chance they are with a 24%), search out someone that will do the ultrasound procedure. With your new diet, unless there is still something bugging you like eggs or nuts, etc, the stones should not return. – valkyrie Mar 8 2011 at 19:37
2

I wish I'd heard of it before mine was removed.

I probably wouldn't have been ready to hear it then, though.

When the student is ready, the teacher appears :-)

link|flag
Me, too, anonymo-paleo! – Rhonda Mar 8 2011 at 14:19
Same. Lost mine in my early 20s. Turned out it was a different minor issue and the gallbladder, along with the rest of my body was perfectly healthy. – sean Mar 8 2011 at 16:41
1

did you have a sonogram to determine if it were gall stones? if yes, could you update and post if there were indeed stones which have been flushed out confirmed by a subsequent sonogram.

link|flag
1 
I had the Hida-Scan, the most comprehensive test for gall bladder functioning. It was at 24% functioning where 50% is normal. The cut-off for surgery decisions is about 35%. – AndyH Mar 8 2011 at 16:20
0

I have had the HIDA and have zero percent ejection factor. I don't want to have my gallbladder removed, and want to at least try to heal. My surgeon is actually very supportive and wants me to keep him filled in about my progress. There are no studies that have been done on people healing their gallbladders--since surgery is done so frequently. My healing process may bring about healing in my gallbladder, or it may not, but at least I want to try.

As anyone else out there had healing with a zero ejection factor?

link|flag

Your Answer

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.