Blog

14

1

So I like pretty much everything so far about being primal/paleo. I love eating more meat and fat, I had no problem eliminating grains. The problem I'm having is sugar, and it's derailing everything. Sugar (especially chocolate) is my cryptonite. I've tried most of the hacks -- better quality/lower sugar chocolate, other replacements, simply trying to wait it out. I go about a week eating some plain yogurt with chocolate chips (or something similar) and will then binge horribly one night on Reeses or M&Ms.

It no longer feels like an issue of mere willpower. I can eat at Panera and resist bread, where I once used to eat it as a snack and loved nothing better than peanut butter and butter toast. I've given up rice and 95% of processed foods. But when I try to go a night without sugar, I get antsy and shaky and wind up prowling my house like a caged animal. I'm starting to doubt that I can ever conquer this, and it's VERY important that I do, because I'm also a type 1 diabetic and this behavior is going to slowly kill me :( Every single reason, from my blood sugars to my freakin' siuze 16 jeans never seem important when it really comes to crunch time.

Have any of you dealt with a carb/sugar addiction this bad? If so, what can I do about it?

flag
EFT (Emotional Freedom Techniques) is very effective for cravings. Check out this video:thetappingexperience.com/EFT/?page_id=2 – Dragonfly Aug 18 2011 at 1:07

13 Answers

21

The only way to kick the sugar habit is to completely eliminate it. Sugar is like a drug, having just a little leaves you craving more. You can't do better quality and lower sugar chocolate or replacements and expect success. You must completely eliminate it to get over your cravings.

link|flag
Totally agree on this. Cold turkey is the only way to go. – Karen Mar 11 2011 at 23:59
I agree. The first week and a half was the hardest but the weeks after that were much easier. Now recently I tried adding a little back in and started eating to much. Now I crave it all the time so I will be cutting out once again - if your addicted it's the only way. – Eazine Aug 18 2011 at 3:12
Definitely. You don't give cocaine addicts or alcoholics a little bit of their addictive substance. You cut it out entirely. You have do this with sugar. I managed without it for years and did not even want it. – EnglishRose May 26 at 17:15
6

Are you still eating a fair amount of carbohydrate/glucose from other sources? Do potato and other "paleo" starches and carb sources make up a large amount of your diet? If so that could be a problem: you might not be able to ditch the sugar until you ditch those.

This was certainly the case with me. Whenever I tried to cut out soda and sweets but continued eating medium to high carb I would always start eating soda and sweets again, slowly but surely.

My thought is that it goes something like this: your body needs to switch over its metabolism; you need to get it used to burning more fats and less glucose. Otherwise you're going to continue to want the most extreme, easy-to-deliver form of your preferred fuel source. Your body senses a deficit of its primary fuel and wants to make up the deficit as quickly as possible.

It's not this way for everyone but it definitely was for me, and I've heard anecdotal evidence from others along the same lines.

If this applies to you, then try going low carb for a while, eating lots of fat. Your body will change and your mind will change along with it. After a couple of weeks of this, if you cheat and have a significant amount of sugar, you'll pay the price because it will make you feel miserable. You may not even want the sugar in the first place because it will probably taste overwhelmingly sweet, maybe even nauseatingly sweet.

And then presumably you'd be able to go back to eating carbohydrate after you kicked your sugar habit. (Or you could just never go back, like me!)

link|flag
I'm the same. The sugar cravings went away when I cut way back on the carbs and added more coconut oil & other fats to my diet. I was still eating a few squares of chocolate a day, and I didn't mind that, but later, after I started taking more mineral supplements and drinking mineral water, I found I would forget to eat chocolate. I've heard it's mostly the magnesium that relates to chocolate. – Robin Mar 12 2011 at 14:11
6

I found supplementing with L-Glutamine helped put the nail in the sugar coffin for me. I used a high-quality powder and even took it by the spoonful under my tongue when a serious craving came up. Nora Gedgaudas (Primal Body, Primal Mind) talks about it's use in breaking addiction.

I found it somewhere in here.

link|flag
Also recommend this book Primal Body, Primal Mind, by Nora Gedgaudas – FanOfSunshine Mar 11 2011 at 22:32
Looks like I can get a small amount from VitaminShoppe pretty cheap -- definately worth a shot, thanks! :) – GeishaGirl Mar 14 2011 at 19:29
Sounds great, thanks for sharing! – Risssa Mar 19 2011 at 3:29
I've tried it too and had it yesterday and today. Worth a try. Perhaps also chromium picolinate tablets as well. – EnglishRose May 26 at 17:17
6

I had terrible sugar addiction. I kept making excuses like "Just this one more time." One day I had to say to myself "ok, no excuses today". You have to realise the cravings are coming from a very primitive emotional part of the brain and your rational thinking brain is no match for it. I then got through the sugar withdrawal with lots and lots coffee and diet cola. Not ideal, but it's what I needed. Two weeks later I could deal with the caffeine withdrawal.

link|flag
2

Do you know someone who can handcuff you to a chair when your cravings kick in?

link|flag
1

Geisha Girl - when you have those cravings at night, try Yogi Peach Detox tea. The wonderful flavors of cinnamon, cardamom and others have a really soothing effect. Also try adding cinnamon to your food, or take a cinnamon supplement. It doesn't CURE your cravings overnight, but does help soothe the sugar monster.

L-Glutamine can help as Riveted suggested, but also consider BCAA's (branched chain amino acids) in general before and after a workout.

Try these things for a minimum of 3 weeks, but do take it one day at a time.

link|flag
1

Google how to manage hypoglycemia. Withdrawal symptoms are expected during the first several months. Then sugar, etc. won't even bother you like it never existed.

link|flag
I'm a type 1 diabetic -- hypoglycemia isn't much of a problem, and when it is, I have my trusty sugar tester to find out :) But thanks :) – GeishaGirl Mar 14 2011 at 19:26
1

The only way I know is to just quit cold turkey. Some folks use Stevia - though it's not Paleo I believe it is safe, and has been used for centuries. But I'm of the school of thought that it's just "candy cigarettes," and only keeps your sweet tooth alive. Best course of action is to just let your taste buds adjust to a non-sweetened world.

link|flag
0

It is HARD. Just when I think I'm in control, I get sucked back in. The longer you go without it, the easier it gets. I've learned that I can't keep temptations in the house -- I can't stop at just one bite. Right now, I'm trying to discipline myself by giving up all sweets for Lent -- no desserts, dark chocolate, artificial sweeteners, etc. I told a few people, too, so there is some accountablility.

link|flag
0

My 25 yr old daughter has suffered from sugar addiction for at least 5 years - and its getting worse. She has gone up to five weeks eating "normally" and then craters and binges on sugar, french fries, pizza, and lots of ice cream and candies for days - its seriously affecting her life and job. Amazingly she is a size 6 but yo yos back and forth up to 20 pounds in just a few weeks. Its just killing us - how can we help her? I've suggested hypnotism - has anyone tried it along with all the other "tricks", diets, supplements, etc...?

Has anyone tried a clinic (i.e. food addiction clinic similar to Betty Ford for alcoholics)? We are getting desperate!

link|flag
has she tried counseling/anti-depressants? i know this is an old thread but my heart breaks for this girl :( – Rebekah Mar 18 2012 at 16:14
lef.org/magazine/mag2009/… 'Sorry no one chimed in earlier. I'm having some real problems right now myself. I hope things are going better for you and your daughter. Dr. Marshak has some great ideas re: addiction. Also, Nora Gedgaudas is very Paleo/Primal and suggests supplements as well. Good luck; I hope things get better. – Marty - Ecotone Wellness Apr 3 2012 at 5:59
0

I'm in no way an expert in any sense of the word but I do a fair amount of Paleo research and it seems like a lot of people are talking about getting the right fats for getting your brain health/mental well being in order. A craving is mental too, not just a growling stomach. Really look into the Omega3/Omega6 ratio issue and get lots of good saturated fats like coconut oil and see what happens. The magnesium mentioned is also a great suggestion for cutting out chocolate specifically since your body wants that for the right reason, sugar just hijacked that particular Mg train. Natural Calm ftw.

link|flag
0

Balanced Bites has a 21-day Sugar Detox. We haven't done it because we're not too "in" to sugar. We'd both rather fill up on a huge steak instead of popping a few M&Ms or some Reese's.

We've both heard of good things about Balanced Bites, and Diane seems like she'd be a good coach for you.

Maybe give it a shot? Or, avoid the candy aisles at your grocery store, forever.

Natural Calm is another great product. I (Kylie) have been taking it for a few days and notice I just feel better.

link|flag
0

First, you have to realize it's not an addiction at all. It's due to insulin resistance. When your cells become insulin resistant you make more and more insulin to overcome it. Your body is producing so much insulin that it's sending all the sugar you consume straight to be stored as fat so now there's not enough sugar left in your bloodstream to provide you with energy. So, your blood sugar keeps crashing and your body keeps screaming for more sugar in the hopes of getting enough energy. The key is to eat a low carb diet and get yourself switched over to burning fat for energy. For me it takes about three days to shut off the cravings. For those three days though you will have to resist the urge for sugar and make sure you eat something else anytime hunger strikes.

link|flag
attraction to sugar isn't all about insulin resistance. when sugar is consumed, it effects the opiate and dopamine receptors in the brain the same way that drugs - like nicotine and cocaine - do. there is some connection to the typical addictions people think of. – Ruth Aug 19 2011 at 12:14
If your analogy is true then shouldn't a taste of it cause a binge? That doesn't happen though. As long as you don't have enough to kick you out of ketosis you can have it without triggering a binge. I'm one of those people who used to think it was addictive. It's not the same process at all. It's your body dying for some quick energy. Yes, it does set up some powerful cravings. I'm not denying that. As far as your body knows, it's in danger of starving. When you are hungry that gives you some powerful cravings too, but you wouldn't use that as proof that you are addicted to food. – turkeytyme Aug 19 2011 at 18:46
Only problem with this is that I'm a type 1 diabetic -- I'm producing NO insulin, and having NO sugar crashes. I know, because I monitor my blood 5-10 times per day :) Trust me, it's a detox. I described my symptoms to a friend with a heroin addiction, and she said it was exactly what she went through. – GeishaGirl Aug 19 2011 at 23:44
It is an addiction, not insulin resistance. Read "Potatoes Not Prozac" for more information on sugar addiction. I don't follow her advice, but her description of the problem is spot on. – Paula Mar 31 2012 at 0:42
Yes des maisons in the Potatoes book gets it right. – EnglishRose May 26 at 17:44

Your Answer

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.