Blog

0

I was wondering about ketosis and high fat/low carb diets and taking that to the extreme, what would happen if a person took in very low carbs and very low protein. Like, drank normal calories worth of coconut milk for 2 days? 3 days? 1 week? 2 weeks?

Just curious.

flag

6 Answers

3

Dietary fat is chemically a triglyceride. 3 fatty acids bound to a glycerol molecule. Glycerol can actually be turned into glucose and my guess is that much of the dietary glycerol would be turned into glucose, possibly providing a fair amount. But I think you would probably catabolize your muscles to a degree.

It would be a downward spiral to say the least.

link|flag
Hrm, interesting. Yeah, that's kind of what I was thinking. But I can't help but think about epileptic children who are put on high fat diets and highly restrictive with carbs and proteins ... what about them? – Joyce L. Mar 31 2011 at 4:25
I think they at least get 10% as proteins. As I know it the diets have to be very high in coconut fat so as to maximize ketone production and minimize glucose needs. Medium-chain fats get turned to ketone bodies much more prolifically than long-chain fats. We're talking at least 50% of cals as coconut. I think you can sustain that indefinitely. – Stabby Mar 31 2011 at 4:45
2

The Perfect Health Diet (perfecthealthdiet.com) advocates ~70% fat. The Optimal Diet recommends ~80% fat. PaNu for weight loss recommends ~80% fat as well, and for healthy people who don't need to lose weight the PaNu fat macro is still high at around ~65-75% (though he doesn't stress particular macro ratios, if you're doing it right, it'll come out to those percentages anyhow).

The only diets that are 90%+ fat are, as you've noted, therapeutic ketogenic diets and 'fat fasts' where consumption is completely fats, and in those cases it is a last resort. If you're not experiencing terrible suffering or life-threatening conditions then why would you event want to go above 80%? Perfecthealthdiet.com has a series on risks of prolonged diets without adequate starches/carbs, and PaNu has recently come out in favor of starches up to 20% (depending on activity level) as very healthy.

It is really easy to stay in the above recommended ranges--have your meals just be meat/fish/eggs with a side of veggies/tubers all drowned in butter/coconut oil. Very simple, very healthy, and best of all, very tasty!

link|flag
1 
This is true. Paul at PerfectHealthDiet recommends going a single way with only coconut fat so as to reap the benefits of autophagy on a weekly basis. I don't see it being a good thing beyond that. Supposedly a week of fasting every year is a good thing, but yeah not long-term that's for sure. – Stabby Mar 31 2011 at 5:31
Can you post the link to where Paul at PHD recommends this one day a week fat fast? Much appreciated. I do IF and am planning to do a week of water fasting semi-yearly. – haig Mar 31 2011 at 17:27
1

Death from the lack of essential amino-acids.

link|flag
1

Diarrhea would be the first side-effect.

link|flag
0

I'm wondering about this myself because I lost a lot of weight my first week of paleo but so far this week I've gained two pounds. I've been super super strict, unlike my boyfriend who still is eating sandwiches and protein shakes (on paleo, he says).

I'm desperate. I'm going to do a day where all I do is coconut milk or avocados and see what happens.

link|flag
2 
I wouldn't do avocados. Too many O-6's. Do all coconut, or butter, or cream. Though ease into coconut. I spent a few days as captain of the SS Porcelain when I went (pardon my french) balls deep with the coconut milk/oil. Not fun. – Joan Mar 31 2011 at 13:44
I wouldn't mind that as long as it meant I was losing weight. I don't understand my body at all. I feed it good food and its supposed to want to be thin, but no! Gain gain gain! Ugh. I cannot win :( – Oranges13 Mar 31 2011 at 13:50
1 
I feel the same way, I can't lose weight. I'm off fruit totally so I'm just eating protein, fat and vegetables plus exercising and I've lost a total of 5 pounds in 45 days, and it goes up and and down by two pounds all the time, can't win either. – Lauren Mar 31 2011 at 15:55
..oh and I'm supposedly in ketosis (based on ketostix reading) and still not losing. – Lauren Mar 31 2011 at 15:56
0

Maybe you're gaining muscle which weighs more while loosing fat.

link|flag

Your Answer

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.