Blog

3

Just started to add fermented vegetables to my diet and yesterday I see this -- http://www.slate.com/id/2295964/

Anyone have any thoughts on if this holds any weight or something we should be concerned about??

flag
2 
ack! what doesn't cause cancer ;) ? – Thumper Jun 6 2011 at 22:55

7 Answers

4

Supposedly, there is a rise in stomach and throat cancer that is sometimes linked to kimchi here. Then again, it could be the fact that it's all fermented in hot pepper, eaten at nearly every meal. It could also be that alcoholism doesn't exist here even though the people do in fact drink a lot and smoke heavily.

link|flag
Wait, so are you saying that they're in denial that they drink a lot, or that they aren't addicted to it/don't have problem drinkers? – Sara Jun 6 2011 at 23:27
South Korea was recently rated the 7th drunkest country in the world, but they do not see it as a problem, though in the US, we'd considerate it rampant alcoholism. – MimsySeoul Jun 7 2011 at 3:55
2

I'm thinking that this part of the article is key:

"...nutrients that enable fresh vegetables to prevent cancer may degrade in the acidic solution."

The people getting the cancer often eat the fermented vegetables in lieu of fresh for long periods of time when they are not available.

link|flag
3 
Not preventing cancer is not the same thing is causing it. – Matt Oct 21 2011 at 21:59
Michelle is illustrating the inconclusive nature of statistics. – Kashkillz Dec 12 at 22:23
2

I was drafted back in 1972, went to Korea and I became fond of Kimchi both for taste and health. As you get older digestion becomes ever important. At 59 I'm in pretty good health. No phamaceutical drugs and still under 200 lbs at 6 ft. tall.

I just feel I need to increase my digestion quality and have read that the U.S. is one of the few societies in the world that doesn't eat a fermented food on a consistent basis. I'm not in favor of milk based products like yogart, as I live in So. Florida, sub tropics and I believe that milk is to fattening for this climate. I don't think people living in the tropics need the level of body fat that people in the colder climates need, especially animal fats.

What I'm looking for is a healthy recipe for fermenting vegetables, that actually tastes good. I could go to Kimchi, but a little spicy hot for my general taste.

I believe more in the Hulda Clark concept that cancer is caused by enviromental contaminants, various parasitic infestations, i.e. fungi, bacterias, intestinal flukes, etc. and of course poor neutrition.

Any good recipes out there???

link|flag
When I ferment vegetables, I put them in a brine that has the same spices and ratios as when the vegetables are cooked in the soups, stews, or stir fry that I normally eat. – mth Oct 21 2011 at 15:08
I make homemade sauerkraut with this device called the "pickl-it" which has a sealed gas escape system so you don't have to scrape any mold off (though it is harmless) and there are some great recipes on her website. I want to try pickles too, but the kraut is amazing, no whey or culture starter, just salt. – Jackie Oct 21 2011 at 16:52
you can pickle unripe papaya. I know they sell it at Tropical traditions. – Aughra Oct 21 2011 at 20:24
1

Somebody with free time can check out the full article year and critique it. The authors are Japanese and Korean cancer researchers. Go toward the bottom and click PDF or HTML.

http://onlinelibrary.wiley.com/doi/10.1111/j.1349-7006.2009.01374.x/abstract;jsessionid=6CF2FB8C981E455000FF4966C404A6CD.d03t03

Actually, I just realized, it's not original research. It's what they call "meta research", meaning they looked at research to date and came up with their own conclusions. This is the same thing done by Frank Hu, who came to conclude that saturated fat is not associated with CVD.

In any case, it is a bit alarming since it is not based on some isolated research but on the totality of accumulated research to date. So someone with free energy and time can take a look and critique it. Also, it would be nice to see if the same conclusion might apply to other Paleo-friendly fermented foods: Sauerkraut; Kombucha; Kefir; yogurt; and what do you call that fermented beet stuff?

link|flag
Beet kvass (my Russian husband likes to argue with me that it is not, in fact, kvass, but just pickles beets and that only the rye kvass deserves to be called kvass.) – Aughra Jun 7 2011 at 2:31
As a Russian, I 2nd your husband's arguement :P – romesaz Oct 21 2011 at 15:22
1

Here's some speculation on mechanisms from the paper:

Salt is not a directly acting carcinogen, but consumption of salt and salt-preserved foods may cause atrophic gastritis by directly damaging the gastric mucosa, which could induce DNA synthesis and cell proliferation that contributes to stomach carcinogenesis(67) or enhance the penetration of carcinogens.(68) In addition, it has been reported that a high-salt diet enhances H. pylori colonization in the stomach.(69)Helicobacter pylori infection may increase the endogenous synthesis of nitrate in the stomach and decrease gastric vitamin C concentrations,(70) thereby increasing endogenous N-nitroso compound formation.(16) For these reasons, a high intake of salt and salt-preserved foods has been considered a probable cause of GC in many studies.(16,36,40,51,54,71,72) The loss of antioxidants in fresh vegetables as a consequence of processing and storage under acid and oxygen might partially explain the harmful effects of consumption of pickled vegetables on GC risk.(15,20,21) Another possible explanation is that pickled vegetables are a possible food source of nitroso compounds, thereby contributing to gastric carcinogenesis.(22,23)>

link|flag
1 
i'm not giving up sauerkraut. – Andy Oct 21 2011 at 20:10
Yup. I figured salt was the most likely culprit. – David Moss Oct 22 2011 at 8:41
1

It is possible to ferment vegies without salt.

link|flag
0

This is good recipe - works for me! The book is good too...

http://www.wildfermentation.com/resources.php?page=sauerkraut

link|flag

Your Answer

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.