Blog

16

1

*"...focus on becoming leptin sensitive by eating 50 grams of protein at breakfast everyday within 30 minutes of rising..."* The Quilt

Since many have been discussing The Quilt's recommendations for overcoming leptin resistance, I would love to hear from anyone who EATS this much protein within 30 minutes of rising. What are you eating? I had 3 eggs and half a strip of bacon this morning which is only 20 g according to Fit Day. That was all I could eat and the amount was too much. I usually eat 2 eggs. I thought about adding a 20 g shake but it just did not sound appetizing.

Does anyone manage to eat this much protein within 30 minutes of rising? If so, would you share what you eat? I have been skipping breakfast for about four months with ease and I thought I might give this a try to see if it would help with losing stubborn fat. Also, how important is the 30 minute requirement? Working out on an empty stomach is more comfortable for me, so I prefer to eat about 2 hours after rising. The large meal and the time constraints might make this protocol too difficult to fit in with my work obligations.

I would like to hear from everyone but would particularly like to hear from people with smaller appetites and females.

flag
2 
Thanks for the question. And I am wondering if the 50 grams applies equally to males and females. I, too, skip breakfast most days (not hungry) and I am wondering if I should force myself to eat. – Annie Jun 8 2011 at 16:13
2 
you make a work excuse....here is what i tell my patients.....before bed throw in a huge slab of grass fed meat and left over veggies and organic beefstock in the crock pot.....at 8PM Set for ten hours. You got substrate for breakfast and your eggs. Leverage sleep. Use a thought to better your DNA. It is not that hard. – The Quilt Jun 8 2011 at 16:33
19 
@The Quilt: "Use a thought to better your DNA?" Asking a question to determine if there are acceptable ranges for males/females and time issues IS "using a thought". You might try "using a thought" that text limitations might not convey someone's determination or intelligence. If 'within 30 mins of rising' is an absolute then adjusting my workout schedule is a possible solution to consider and definitely not an excuse. – texasleah Jun 8 2011 at 19:08
2 
What about those who are leptin resistant and have LOW cortisol in the morning? Will eating a big serving of protein within 30 min of waking be beneficial for them too? – Gazelle Jun 8 2011 at 19:38
3 
Thank you Alex for your nice comment, and I am not insulted by Quilt's brusque manner. Although I pointed out that text has its limitations in conveying meaning, Quilt's response was that my 'excuse' was not thinking hard enough on how to turn the crockpot on at bedtime. – texasleah Jun 8 2011 at 19:54
show 10 more comments

17 Answers

13

I think the point many are missing is that the leptin re-sensitization meal plan (whether it actually works or not, I have no idea) is for people who are Leptin-insensitive. It is meant to be followed for 6-8 weeks (I believe) only. Normal paleo eating can resume after this time period. It is not intended for those who are leptin-sensitive.

link|flag
1 
Amazing you got it...... – The Quilt Jun 8 2011 at 23:31
Concise, considerate explanation Alex! – texasleah Jun 9 2011 at 15:08
"Her goal is to focus on becoming leptin sensitive by being required by eating 50 grams of protein at breakfast everyday within 30 minutes of rising, eliminating all snacking especially past 730 PM, eating three meals a day, and limiting her carb intake below fifty grams per day for about 6-8 weeks." – texasleah Jun 9 2011 at 15:10
@The Quilt: the sentence above from your blog post (which I enjoyed very much, thank you) made me think that you meant to limit carbs below 50g per week for 6-8 weeks. I understand you now to mean to do the entire protocol for 6-8 weeks. But in answering your four leptin status questions, I think I am past that now. – texasleah Jun 9 2011 at 15:13
12

I absolutely do not ever do this and really couldn't with where I keep my calories per day to keep from gaining weight.

I prep all my food, so time is not an issue. From my own n=1 experiments, I know higher protein works for me, but I need to spread my meals throughout the day. When I do IF, skipping breakfast is much easier than skipping lunch. I cannot eat and then workout, at all, so if I tried to eat 30 mins after waking I wouldn't be able to workout either.

It may be that I am permanently causing leptin problems, but mentally I know I could not accomplish this goal. I might be able to pull off 30 grams within an hour of waking. Maybe as a smaller female with lower calorie requirements this would work?

Edit - For new users. I am 40 years old and formerly obese. I have to watch my calories closely. I know a lot of you believe that if I just ate the "RIGHT" combination of Paleo foods that I would not have to pay attention to calories and trust me, I wish that were true, but it is not. I prefer not to be attacked as not doing the research or not knowing what I was talking about because what my body does is different than what your body does. It's disenheartening to log on and find attacks on questions that are months old. DO YOUR RESEARCH, PLEASE. LOOK AT MY PAST QUESTIONS/ANSWERS BEFORE YOU ASSUME I DON'T KNOW WHAT I'M TALKING ABOUT. Thanks.

link|flag
9 
If you can somehow ignore the fact that you are destroying your leptin sensitivity by not eating within 30 minutes of eating, you might, possibly, still be able to lead a healthy and fulfilling life. Be sure to tell Martin Berkhan and friends at leangains that they could lose some weight if they stop their intermittent fasting. Especially the ones who were overweight and surely leptin resistent before starting IFing. I hate myself for being so sarcastic, but what tools are left to use when logic and precision fail? Melissa, you might have to give me some instructions on maintaining civility. – Kamal Jun 8 2011 at 18:32
3 
kamal, the only option at this point is disengagement. unless you have the restraint and willpower of my dear melissa here, which i do not. my mediterranean temperament very well might override my tongue if i get involved. im glad melissa is a grownup, because im sure not. – being Jun 8 2011 at 18:40
7 
Just call me The Ostrich, I shall live with my head in the sand regarding my leptin sensitivity, while enjoying my 111 lb weight loss and smokin new body. ;) – sherpamelissa Jun 8 2011 at 18:43
2 
Uh oh, I don't want to see the storm that brews if akd goes off. Introducing...The Armenian Nightmare! Ostrich, I'm joining you on the sidelines now. The summer weather is too warm for Comforters, Blankets, and the like. – Kamal Jun 8 2011 at 19:22
3 
WOW, CODY. TRUST ME. I'M INFORMED. I'VE READ IT. WHAT I AM SAYING IS THAT IT ~DOES NOT WORK FOR ME~. I AM FORMERLY OBESE AND CANNOT EAT THAT MUCH PROTEIN TO START THE DAY OR I WOULD NOT HAVE ENOUGH CALORIES LEFT FOR THE REST OF THE DAY. YES. I PRESCRIBE TO CALORIES IN/CALORIES OUT. IT IS WHAT WORKS FOR MY BODY. I WISH IT DIDN'T. – sherpamelissa Nov 1 2011 at 12:37
show 5 more comments
8

4 eggs + 1 can of red salmon + onions = heaven and closer to 70g.

link|flag
Bravo! Do you scramble the eggs and mix with the salmon? Or eat separately? Maybe I could do half a can and two eggs cooked together... – texasleah Jun 8 2011 at 16:12
2 
4 eggs to anything easily makes this. Why do people make things harder than they really are? plus one dude. – The Quilt Jun 8 2011 at 16:31
I agree, I can't eat 4 eggs I use egg white and spinach! Just a suggestion, and I have to agree with the "quilt" it seems to be the important part to the our weight loss, the 30 min. eating after waking! : ) – Diane S Jun 27 2011 at 14:05
7

here is the answer i posted to Jac in the comments.....I think it lays out why I believe what I believe.

"For most overweight paleo’s I want them loading up for breakfast. 50-75 gms is routine. Four egg omelettes with a serious side of bacon is how I roll my breakfast. On surgery days I make a killer coconut smoothie with raw eggs and coconut milk and heavy cream. You will never be hungry if you eat a breakfast like this. the biochemistry behind this recommendation is why……very detailed but I will post it at some point if people are interested."

"The reason I advocate this Jac is that recent study out of the University of Missouri was done with teenage girls and protein in the morning. They used functional MRI to validate the work which is a first. The results confirm what I always knew from biochemistry. Eating protein as soon as you rise control hunger and lowers AM cortisol very quickly. Both huge factors for health. If your not hungry you wont over eat and get fat and develop the inflammation that causes disease. Cortisol effect is huge too. Be sure to read my Hormone 101 blog of why it is critical to keep your cortisol low. The girls ate no breakfast, 18 grams of protein and 50 grams of protein. Then they showed the girls a picture of food before lunch. The low protein girls (no protein and 18 grams groups) hypothalamus lit up like crazy on the functional MRI while those who ate 50 grams of protein functional MRI had no areas light up. questionaires also were used with the girls and the low protein girls all were hungry while the girls who ate 50 grams of protein were not. This proves the biochemistry on a neuro-anatomic level. That is why I tell people to eat a ton of protein at breakfast"

link|flag
7 
That's a nice story Doc. Really, it is. But do you think it warrants a blanket recommendation regarding something this important. Teenage girls? I mean... good for them, but I usually like to see more than just this before coming to a conclusion. I'm sure you have more that contributed to your conclusion, so I don't mean to dash the whole concept, but personally, I usually do not desire anything at all within 30 minutes or rising, and I've been that way every day for as long as I can remember. Plus, is meat and eggs the only solution? 7 days a week? – Jack Kronk Jun 8 2011 at 17:41
5 
Lucky I think there are many ways to skin this cat......my point is this......fat causes inflammation and inflammation kills you. My job is to keep you healthy and this works. I am not going to get in a pissing contest over how and what......I am about the WHY. Way more important to my goal and my patients goals. It gets to the core issues of how to get people to change. – The Quilt Jun 8 2011 at 18:27
5 
you're not a nobody!! i appreciate you and your blanket-less statements. – Kamal Jun 8 2011 at 20:00
4 
I understand where you're coming from completely, but even though Dr. K may be a bit forceful or oblique at times, he is exploring a field of dietary nutrition that not many others are embarking upon. And this seems to be met by many people (some with personal grudges, it seems) with fierce indignation instead of fair thought. I wasn't really trying to "white knight" anything or defend anyone, and I'm sorry if you felt that way. It's just I don't understand why many feel the need to be resistant against proposed new ways. After people try it, and we hear their results, we'll know if it works. – Alex Jun 8 2011 at 20:04
4 
alex, the thing that's led most of us here is what turned out to be a very healthy skepticism. i don't know dr k. i've read his thoughts on here and looked at his blog. let me put this bias of mine out there: unabashed certainty, especially in a field like this raises a red flag for me. with the history of cutting edge ideas in the field of health being later found to be at best ineffective and many times harmful, i would hope that a dr would speak with a bit more care when it comes to matters that haven't even had clinical trials. i applaud you for your choice of profession. – luckybastard Jun 8 2011 at 20:21
show 22 more comments
7

i dont know that i could eat 50g in one sitting, let alone wile my feet are still under the covers. my appetite is small, and protein fills me up fast. it would be a brick sitting in my stomach and there is no way i would be able to exercise at all. i have always preferred to exercise on an empty stomach, particularly cardio and yoga. seriously, just thinking about it makes me feel like i want to vomit. which is exactly what i would likely do. i want to lose another 35 pounds, but the idea of eating anything first thing in the morning, let alone a big hunk of cold leftover steak, half a dozen eggs and four cans of tuna or whatever really makes me sick.

ive already lost 33 pounds or so breaking my fast around 11am or so, so im going to stick with what works for me.

link|flag
12 
you can make excuses all you want...it's your life...look at levee number 27 and read up on your biochem. your perception is like an ant looking through a magnifying glass...i am the magnifying glass manufacturer. – Kamal Jun 8 2011 at 19:46
9 
get your ultra sensitve CRP cheked...report back...ina gadda da vida... – Kamal Jun 8 2011 at 19:54
7 
paleohacks without Kamal would just plain suck :) – texasleah Jun 8 2011 at 19:58
8 
if work is boring...turn up the furnace of oxidative phosphorylation...play with your partners nipples....my endgame is more nipple play for those i influence or else i haven't done my job – Kamal Jun 8 2011 at 20:20
14 
masterjohn and i agree...magic number dependes on telemoere damage...hit me baby one more time... – Kamal Jun 8 2011 at 21:53
show 26 more comments
6

broke my fast at 11:30(woke up at 6am) with a lb of ground beef mixed in with some cabbage. no hunger. i think the distinction needs to be made between someone on a SAD being hungry and overeating as opposed to one on a paleo diet who is keto-adapted. i fast 24 hours at will with no problems and i know of many other paleos who have the same testimony. i've read enough studies and commentary over at martin berkhan's site to not really worry about muscle catabolism because of eating in a 6-8 hour window. in fact, i look at my ability to fast as a good indicator of where i am metabolically at the moment- i take it to mean that i'm pretty efficient at switching over between the glycolytic and ketogenic pathways.

link|flag
2 
Dr. K did mention the overweight. I wonder if keto adapted are different? I am not overweight and I do VLC. Not hungry until the afternoon most days. – Annie Jun 8 2011 at 19:00
2 
they all gloss over context.......plus one. – The Quilt Jun 8 2011 at 19:08
3 
Ok, so in context you mean "eat 50 g of protein within 30 minutes of waking" only for those who are newly off of SAD, not keto adapted and have appetite all day long? – texasleah Jun 8 2011 at 19:24
6 
I don't think we were given a context to gloss over. – sherpamelissa Jun 8 2011 at 19:35
8 
Actually, your blog post may have given the context, but it certainly wasn't mentioned here. I went back andchecked. I am no where neAr resistant to new ideas. I just want to understand them before I implement new protocols. And I might not be able to scientifically explain plateus, but I have definitely busted thru a few of them and helped others do it too. – sherpamelissa Jun 9 2011 at 2:46
show 4 more comments
5

I just broke my fast with nearly 100g of protein from eating 12 of my delicious homemade meatballs, leftover from last night. It was quite easy - I've been up since 6:00 and didn't eat anything. Then for 'breakfast' (at about 12:30) I started out with some tabata burpees and kettlebell swings. I was ravenous after that, so down the hatch they went.

Oops, looks like I forgot to eat :30 after waking.

link|flag
If you could just man up and chug down that protein before the clock strikes 6:30, you could be a concert violinist in your spare time while singlehandedly solving all of the world's political problems. – Chickenosaurus Rex Jun 9 2011 at 3:29
As long as it works around the nap schedule! :) – sherpamelissa Jun 9 2011 at 13:32
5

day 3 and still willing to do it again tomorrow.

day 1 i had back bacon and 2 eggs. day 2 i had chicken breast and 2 eggs. today i had 2 small pork chops and 2 eggs...its getting a bit eggy. tonight i have pork belly in the crock pot so i can slow cook beef in the fat over night.

i am seriously considering buying some protein powder for something a little different because i find it hard to eat three times a day with such a huge morning meal.

i definitely believe i am leptin insensitive although i have no blood work to confirm this. what i wonder is will there be indicators along the way that this is working?

link|flag
2 
thanks for sharing, your question is generally the same as mine. In Quilts Leptin part II on his blog, he has four screening questions that might help you out. – texasleah Jun 10 2011 at 14:38
4

5'4 female, 125 pounds. This is what I've been eating for breakfast on the leptin reset ~

~ 5 fat chicken drumsticks or.. ~ 2 chicken/ thigh quarters or.. ~ about 300g (when raw) chicken breast fried in coconut oil or.. ~ whole can of mackerel eaten with seaweed strips (400g can) or.. ~ medium can of salmon and small can of herring, mixed up eaten with seaweed strips

I roast the chicken pieces at the beginning of the week then just reheat for brekkie. I eat this all within 5-20 minutes of waking up. Was hard the first couple of days, but now I am hungry in the mornings. 50 g + of protein and fat in the morning is nothing for me as neither macronutrients really satiate me much :) I can't stomach strong tastes first thing hence all the chicken and fish.

link|flag
2 
And by gum.... it's working! well I'll be..... This Leptin reset thingey ended a 6 month weight loss/body composition stall for me, and my energy levels are so much better. Much more productive at work due to increased mental acuity. – Grottenolm Nov 1 2011 at 19:39
4

The point is you want to lower that cortisol spike in the AM that arouses you from sleep. Protein is the best way. Fat is second best and carbs will kill you. [Quilt]

Normal levels of cortisol are good in the morrning. It energises you and thats how body works. Unless you have oversecreation, you wont achieve your goals. When I used 50g of protein per breakfast, I could indeed stay longer satisfied but that was not the case every day, some days I would get hungry at 10 AM despite the fact that I stuffed very big meal in the morning, but even if it was longer not that much longer [maybe 2 hours more]. I find that it was easier to skip meal to be honest, but maybe I was boosting myself. At the moment, I eat 5 quail raw eggs for breakfast [which equals to at most 2 hen eggs by size] with 4 brazil nuts and that works better for me. For some reason, I even continued to loose weight. I eat normal paleo lunch at 12 then paleo dinner at 6 then ice cream at 21. Not to mention that i frequently eat starch like potatoes.

I think that unless you are really f*cked up, you don't need to go that high with protein in the morning. Quilt says in hormones 101 that "Once [adipocytes] get high enough (around a Body Mass Index (BMI) of 20-24),(TNF) rises in several tissues. TNF quickly destroys normal hepatic homeostasis." Now, I had BMI ~ 27 almost whole my life and there is meta study claiming that this BMI is most protective when longevity is in question. My liver shows no sign of fat deposits in it. BMI less then 20 is very low for man, and most of all, BMI is stupid maker, you can have harder bones or more muscle. I find the article great otherwise, because everything makes sense and sentence "anytime the body is stressed or inflamed, it up-regulates cholesterol production to make more lifesaving hormones... blocking cholesterol’s production will increase cellular stress." which is very hard to explain to people... I also think that you missed crucial info - anything that chronically elevates your cortisol will induce vitamin C deficiency. For instance this study shows that even marginal deficiency is problematic [guinea pigs are the best models for C studies]. Two primary nutrients for the adrenal glands are B5 and C. The increased adrenal activity, depletes both vitamins from the glands. Keywords: Cushing syndrome, ascorbic acid depletition.

The food prep (cook the night before) is not the issue, the issue is the time to get the appetite ready to ingest a 50 g of protein meal, work out and get to my job by 8AM [texasleah]

You doh't have to workout, you can eat eggs raw and appetite is ready if you repeat it long enough. You wake up starving. Anyway, somehow I, and many other people, find that eating meat at the morning is repulsive (unless its a hot dog).

4 eggs + 1 can of red salmon + onions = heaven and closer to 70g [jake]

You will never be hungry if you eat a breakfast like this. the biochemistry behind this recommendation is why. [Quilt]

I did it 30 days or so... was eating 4 eggs, bacon, nuts and cheeze or yougurt + 10-20g shake for breakfast. Unless you have really big eggs and really big can it isn't even close to 70g. 4 eggs [~16g] + salmon can [~25g] + onion [ trivial] ~ 40g. So, its almost impossible without the shake IMO. Maybe you can do it few days but soon you are out of idea. I finished putting pate on еggs .... :S

What about those who are leptin resistant and have LOW cortisol in the morning? Will eating a big serving of protein within 30 min of waking be beneficial for them too? [Gazzele]

Eating protein as soon as you rise control hunger and lowers AM cortisol very quickly. Both huge factors for health [Quilt]

Meaningless, IMO, for people who can't wake up. Cold showers rise my cortisol and wake me up and practice my thermogenesis (UCP) at the same time. I was never hungry in the morning before I started to force myself. This must mean there are other mechanisms in place, except cushing syndrome.

i think needs to be flushed out with more than one small study of a very specific group [luckybastard]

There is more research, just you didn't bother to do find it bastard. For instance, from my head:

A Reduced Ratio of Dietary Carbohydrate to Protein Improves Body Composition and Blood Lipid Profiles during Weight Loss in Adult Women

Time-of-day-dependent dietary fat consumption influences multiple cardiometabolic syndrome parameters in mice

but I know there are at least couple more...

link|flag
That last link is very interesting; thanks for posting it. – Travis Culp Sep 28 2011 at 16:28
2

I eat a lot of protein per day: 275-300 grams. I don't eat anything whatsoever though until 2-3 hours after waking. I, like many others responded, have no appetite or drive to eat as soon as I rise. I do eat dinner within probably 1 hour of going to bed though. In other words I go to bed with definitely what I would call a full stomach.

After I'm up for 2-3 hours though I do have one serving of whey protein, but this is only approx 24 grams of protein, rapidly assimilated. Then throughout the day I eat. A lot:)

Certainly in the lifting world, kind of since forever, they've always advocated eating protein as soon as you can after waking - usually for two claimed reasons: 1. to avoid getting anywhere even near a catabolic state, and 2. to keep metabolism firing and keep a lid of hunger. Just what they've been saying for years. I obviously don't follow this rule.

link|flag
Our diets are very similar...and presumably our schedules! – Futureboy Jun 10 2011 at 2:15
300 g protein per day ? AFAIK anything higher then 200g is toxic. – majkinetor Sep 28 2011 at 8:59
1

Here is why their is a rec for the big protein load. We are forcing neuroplastic change by changing neurotransmitter learning.

http://jackkruse.com/how-does-the-leptin-rx-work/

link|flag
3 
I understand WHY it is the recommendation and I even get that it works for a lot of people. I'm just saying it doesn't work for me because of the large calorie load first thing in the morning. – sherpamelissa Nov 1 2011 at 13:18
Quilt- as a public service announcement, I thought you should know that there was an, ummm, interesting thread about you posted tonight. Put your battle gear on! paleohacks.com/questions/74180/… – Kamal Nov 2 2011 at 0:53
Shepa, Lots of ladies have said the same thing as you about the 50 grams of protein, 30 min within rising...and find after 4-5 days any problems they had disappeared and immediately start to feel much, much better. FWIW – Dextery Nov 5 2011 at 1:35
I promise you it will. You just have to stick with it. Go look at all the people over at my site or mda who trusted me for ten days.....it becomes easy quick – The Quilt Nov 5 2011 at 13:30
0

Steak and/or liver. Add free range bacon and some eggs if you like.

Easy peasy.

link|flag
0

I posted a similar question and would love an update on how you're doing if you ended up following the protocol. Kruse did say that he NORMALLY recommends 50+ grams, but that less might work for some people. 50+ is a lot of protein for me as well...that's nearly my entire day's intake and I feel like it would just make me feel sick.

I'm not sure why others think it's your problem of not enough prep...I get it...it's not that you don't know WHAT to eat, but it's that you're a smaller female and it makes sense that someone who weights twice as much, 2 feet taller, etc. as you would have different requirements.

I plan on going with less than 50g and testing the waters to see how things play out.

link|flag
0

Hello,

I was just wondering if you need to eat the 50 grams of protein, if you are in a healthy weight range?? I am currently trying to maintain the weight I lost from HCG, but I wouldn't mind losing a few more kgs. I have tried the 50g BAB and boy was it tough after HCG, but I managed to go without eating again till dinner time, which was great! My only concern is that given I weigh 63kg at 170cm, surely my daily requirements would be less than an overweight person?

link|flag
0

Scallops!

I'm female and eat high protein, but keep it lean cos I gain weight easily and fats slow me down.

I had 6 oz of bay scallops this morning with onion, mushrooms, broccoli and kaffir leaves and that clocked me in for 34 grams of protein.

At 100 calories per 4 oz serving, the scallops are a pretty good, lean protein source--w/17-20 grams protein in that 4oz. So, dense protein, if you eat shellfish--and tasty!

(FYI< I'm not doing the 50grm protocol myself because I prefer to stave of food as long as I can every day--works better for me except if I've under-eaten day before and wake up hungry/chompy.)

link|flag
0

250g Steak and 3 Eggs (extra large).. according to Calorie King is 75g Fat and 96.9g Protein. Not the most exciting breakfast but I had to eat the steak :D

link|flag

Your Answer

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.