PaleoHackers, I need your input on my next Paleo project.


3

I have noticed that after I eat cheese I get a lot of mucus in my throat. Is this cause for me to stop eating cheese altogether? If this is an allergy is it due to the casein or something else?

flag

4 Answers

3

~Don't consume anything that causes negative physiological responses, such as excessive mucous production. - Brent Pottenger

Personally, cheese makes me feel weird, so I only eat it on special occasions when it's the best cheese ever and the farmer is there, giving me an angry look.

link|flag
2

You might want to try some organic pastured cheeses and see how they make you feel. I don't notice any problems myself on pastured cheeses but I do with regular cheese. Plus better fat balance!

If that doesn't work, try goat cheese/milk. If that still doesn't work I'm afraid you might not be able to tolerate it >_<

link|flag
2

Yes. For one, dairy is NOT paleo, no matter what Mark Sisson says. Dairy first came about when we became herdspeople, which is around the same time as agriculture became big. There is no such thing as "wild milk" - you don't catch a pregnant buffalo and suck on its nipples.

It is estimated that 75% of adults worldwide show some [lactose intolerance]

via wikipedia

My basic meta-rule is that if it causes bad reactions with a decent chunk of people, we're not genetically made to eat it. Yes, there are flukes, but things like lactose intolerance and peanut allergies are well known.

Mucous is a well known reaction to dairy, and it's the least of your worries.

link|flag
1 
Honestly, I was almost glad when I realized cream and milk were making me sick (cottage cheese, well-drained yogurt and cheese don't). I almost wish the others would make me sick too - makes it much MUCH easier to let go of them! – GHarkness May 13 at 22:00
2 
I know for a fact dairy stalls my weight loss, so I stay away from them, except for some occasional cheese when I eat some of the girlfriend's leftovers... – Aaron Griffin May 13 at 22:29
2

Hi Matt. The sensation of increased mucus may be due to the texture and viscosity of dairy products, and not to an actual increase in mucus production (although cheese does not usually cause the same increased mucus sensation as milk). Studies actually measuring mucus production after drinking milk have failed to show an increase.

A dairy protein allergy may cause increased mucus, but it will also typically cause more severe symptoms such as hives, facial and lip swelling, vomiting and breathing difficulty.

Lactose intolerance causes bloating, nausea, gas and/or diarrhea, but does not usually cause increased mucus in the nose or throat.

If the increased mucus is the only adverse reaction you have from eating cheese, then it's probably ok to keep eating it if you want to.

Link: http://www.abc.net.au/health/talkinghealth/factbuster/stories/2007/11/28/2102703.htm

link|flag

Your Answer

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.