I a beginner IF'er, with about 8 months of 95% paleo eating behind. So far I've had good progress, but I'm still looking into leaning a bit. I'm currently 6'1 and about 174-176 lbs, rough estimate of BF is somewhere around 15%.
The Leangains approach suggest more carbs that I feel "need". My usual calorie intake on workout days is about 2100-2200 with P 30-35% / C 15-20% / F 50-55%.
Is it okay to maintain the high fat intake on workout days, or should I cycle and eat more carbs & less fat on workout days? I'm currently breaking fast around 1-2 pm with about 40-50 g protein, 20-30 grams carbs and 25-35 grams fat, workout at 5 pm and having a postworkout meal (within an hour of finishing workout) of 40-50 grams protein (meat) & 50 grams carbs (sweet potato ) and some 10 grams of fat from the meat. Then I have my subsequent and larger postworkout meal of 60-80 grams of protein, 15-25 grams of carbs (veggies) and 50-70 grams of fat (fatty meats and/or paleo friendly condiments or fat from eggs).
Is this totally wrong? I'm also considering taking BCAAs into use around the workout, and possibly switching from 3 to 2 meals a day, with a little bigger lunch and a big 1300-1500 postworkout dinner just before starting the next fast (would the same macros still work?)
Sounds like someone found leangains.com :)
I've been following leangains for 6 weeks or so. I've gained 4 lbs. in that period, but I don't seem to have accumulated any more fat. On workout days, I keep fat fairly low. I generally eat a pound of lean minute steak and a pound of potato/yam/sweet potato PWO (usually about a 1600 calorie meal -- 130g protein, 130g carbs or so) with a can of fish and some veggies for dinner, often a piece of fruit tossed in somewhere. On non-workout days, I eat typical VLC Paleo -- meat-a-plenty, eggs, bacon, coconut pancakes (my crack), veggies, etc. I've been doing the fast-until-workout protocol where I work out around 11AM and eat around noon. My dinner comes about 5 or 6 hours after that, and that's food for the day. Same pattern on non-workout days, usually.
I haven't added the BCAA yet, but it seems like a good idea. Art de Vany and several EFers on his site swear by BCAA and its effect on protein synthesis. Art even went to far as to say that you should take BCAA to reach your body composition goals, as if it were essential to doing so. He said they weren't terribly important to take once you feel "muscular enough" (my quote, not his).
Anyway, this has just been my experience on leangains. I feel satisfied between workouts and able during workouts. I've made gains, and I've stayed lean. I've done it without high fat on workout days beyond what is in my meat and minor amount of cooking fat. Martin's notion is that on workout days, you want to minimize fat retention and de novo lipogenesis. To do so, keep fat intake low and protein intake high (lean meats) and take in enough carbs to restore liver glycogen. Non workout days are high fat, low carb for obvious, Paleo 101 reasons regarding fat storage.
Thanks for the answers! They were somewhat what I expected. After reading more of Martin's stuff, it seems that lowering the fat intake is probably something I need to do, if leaning out is my goal. Too bad, as I really enjoy the high-fat way-of-eating (who doesn't). What this mean's is a) egg WHITE omelets (haven't thrown yolks away since gone paleo) b) no more HUGE pieces of salmon from the deli for lunch c) stockpiling on sweet potato and lean ground beef and 1/2 a rotisserie chickens for rest day lunches (cant wait to see the faces in the office kitchen).
My hack will be: Maintance cals BW x 13 --> 2275 cals (got the 13 from some topic at Mark's Daily Apple). My goal is to shred 5 pounds, so I'll need a deficit not only for the rest days, but workout days also. Calories added to maintenance on WO days +450 --> workout day calories 2050, 35% protein (190 grams) / 35 % carbs (180 grams) / 30% fat (65 grams) (including fish oil caps). Rest day 1700 calories with 42.5 % protein (180 grams) / 12.5 % carbs (55 grams) / 42.5 % fat (85 grams). In case you're wondering the .5 increments, i have my own spredsheet to figure this s*it out :)
I'll go on with the 8/16hr feed/fast, take 10 grams of BCAA preworkout (and another 10g if working out fasted). I also think I'll change my training frequency (CF:ing 2on/1off) to 4 times a week 1on/1off, more heavy lifts and cutting metcons to 8-10 minutes tops. See what happens.
If MATH is to be trusted, this should create a 2600 calorie weekly deficit, and assuming no change in LBM, a drop of 5 lbs bodyfat in 8 weeks (okay this is just hypothetical, body doesn't work like math :)).
Paleo, Intermittent Fasting, and Rage? 6 Answers
The Thrifty Paleo 18 Answers
Paleo confusion 2 Answers
Paleo + IF + Carb Cycling (maybe keto) 2 Answers