Blog

4

2

when discussing paleo with vegan/vegetarian friends, they always retorted with the claim that aztecs/mayans thrived on grains yet were successful.

"The Aztecs, coming south from the deserts of New Mexico, had in the 14th century occupied sites in the valley of Mexico, an area rich in lakes, whose produce (fowl of many kinds, fish, frogs, water insects, algae) the newcomers adopted with enthusiasm. They flourished and established their dominion over a wide area...Sahagun tells us they feasted...on white tortillas, grains of maize, turkey eggs, turkeys, and all kinds of fruit. "

Also that Gladiators were vegan http://www.archaeology.org/0811/abstracts/gladiator.html

are these claims that cultures that thrived on grains were healthy, even true?

flag

1 Answer

7

Oats were a staple of some primitive cultures in Scotland, and rye grain was a staple of some primitive cultures in the Swiss Alps. Both cultures were studied by Weston Price and he found their health to be excellent, in fact these and other cultures were the basis of his book and the Weston Price Foundation.

He has hypothesized that these grains were much more nutritious than what we buy in our stores because of the way they were growth, in rich soil, at certain altitudes, etc. and how they were prepared, primarily soaked and fermented, which makes them much more nutritious.

These people also got a lot more exercise, exposure to the elements, and led relatively stress-free lives.

Virtually every culture that we know about (which is to say, those that survived well enough to leave remnants) was based on some grain. Cultivation of grains is what made it possible for many of these cultures to exist in the first place. I suppose you could say that these people were all unhealthy and died at an early age. You could also say the same thing about hunter gatherer societies. We will probably never know.

I'm not defending grains in a modern diet, and I avoid them. But their role in history is unmistakeable.

link|flag
1 
Very true: the grain-heavy diets of some of the cultures that Weston Price studied were associated with famously good health. But aside from the care they took to prepare those grains properly, I think it's also important to point out the potentially large inherent differences between rye (or spelt, millet, barley, kamut, etc.), on the one hand, and modern GMO semi-dwarf wheat, on the other. We shouldn't lump all grains together, IMO, any more than we should lump all plant oils together. But UncleLongHair gave the correct answer to Andre's question — in a word: yes. – maurile Aug 11 2011 at 18:53

Your Answer

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.