Blog

11

1

I've always liked my steak very rare. This past week I took a bite when it was raw. It's local, organic and grass fed. I loved it and then proceeded to eat the rest raw. I pulled out another steak for lunch today and I here I am again eating it raw. If I really look at what I'm eating and think about it, it disgusts me. And yet I continue to eat it this way. It tastes so...I don't know, pure, perfect. Whatever. It's like eating low fat your entire life because it's supposed to be the best thing for you and then learning that fat isn't so evil and it tastes pretty great. I have got to hide this little pleasure from my husband. He likes his steak well done and might lose his mind if he sees me eating this. So, are there any benefits to eating it raw besides not having to worry about over cooking your perfect, grass fed steak and ending up with a dry piece of leather? It's tender and juicy raw! :) Is there a way I can feel good about this like I now feel good about eating a high saturated fat diet? Does anyone else do this? I'm feeling like a nut job.

flag
1 
keeperofthehome.org/2008/07/… I eat raw meat all the time. I don't think it's weird at all. It's traditional in many cultures: sushi, tartare, etc. – Bread-Eating Beelzebub Aug 28 2011 at 20:27
youtube.com/… i don't think it's that weird.. :D – hunts-with-wolves Aug 28 2011 at 20:44
1 
My girlfriend and I eat raw filet mignon all the time! I'm talking, salt and pepper, mustard and a fork and knife...that's it. We LOVE steak tartare, sashimi. Raw meat is great! – Futureboy Aug 28 2011 at 22:47
1 
Korion, let it thaw very slightly so that you so that you can slice it really thin. Then make carpaccio. google.com/… mmmmmmmmmmm – Karen Aug 29 2011 at 10:37
1 
Seems risky. The chances of contracting foodborne illness are much higher if you eat steak that hasn't been heated at all. Even if the meat handlers were very careful, it's too easy for pathogens to reach and thrive on the surface. Just barely grilling the surface of the steak reduces this risk significantly. I wouldn't eat raw ground meats. Steak is okay because the core of the meat hasn't been penetrated. However, when you churn everything up, pathogens can spread everywhere. – Elunah Aug 13 at 19:48
show 4 more comments

14 Answers

5

I love raw meat. I am reading Deep Nutrition right now with a wonderful group of maniacs. This is what the author has to say about cooking meat:

"Overcooked meat is tough because its fat, protein, and sugar molecules have gotten tangled and fused together during a wild, heat-crazed chemical orgy. The result is a kind of tissue polymer that requires more work to cut with a knife and more chewing, as well as more time to digest. The worst part is that so many of the nutrients we need are ruined. Ruined nutrients don’t just politely disappear. Once ingested, your body won’t be able to simply flush them down some metabolic drainpipe. When heat kills nutrients, it does so by causing reactions between nutrients, forming new chemical compounds including known carcinogens (such as aromatic hydrocarbons and cyclic amines), as well as other molecular fusions that damage your kidneys and blood vessels.141 When meat is cooked properly, fewer harmful reactions occur.142

So how much heat is too much heat? If, when you slice it, there’s not even a trickle of juice, it’s way overdone. Steak should be juicy and red. I recommend you work your way down to medium rare, and once you get used to that, go for rare. "

Shanahan MD, Catherine (2011). Deep Nutrition: Why Your Genes Need Traditional Food (Kindle Locations 2004-2006). Big Box Books.

link|flag
1 
I've never heard of that book. The author doesn't address raw meat in this passage but the message of the more rare the better certainly make me feel better about raw. – Blueberry Aug 28 2011 at 21:09
Yeah - I wonder about the liability of recommending Raw meats in a popular book - but her explanation of what happens when cooking is interesting. Also there is this guy named Randy Roach who wrote a book called Muscle, Smoke and Mirrors and he advocates an all raw diet - raw meat, eggs, dairy, and CHICKEN! Not going there myself. – none Aug 28 2011 at 22:14
Eeeww, chicken? That's hideous. I can barely stomach it cooked. – Blueberry Aug 28 2011 at 23:52
1 
I love raw meat...Overcooked meat is" You're talking two extremes. There are a lot of options between raw and overcooked. – Talldog Aug 13 at 20:49
3

My BF and I have taken to eating beef that still moos... delicious!

Scientifically speaking, heat reduces B6 content in meat and eggs. From what I understand we only get rich sources of B6 from meat, eggs and raw milk... Heat denatures the natural enzymes and probably other nutrients as well. Cooking may render it more digestible in other ways but will make it less nutritious overall.

It also stands to reason that heating would destroy some of the valuable omega-3s in that tasty grass-fed bliss? Is this so?

I'm not quite at the WAPF's recommendation of eating 50% of my meat raw yet, but do make an effort to cook good quality meat rare, eat some raw egg yolks, and make a raw meat dish on occasion.

link|flag
WAPF recommends 50%!! Really? I'm feeling better about this by the minute. I have been eating raw eggs in my smoothies for a while just to add some protein. I didn't know it was better for B6 content. Great information. Thank you. – Blueberry Aug 28 2011 at 21:11
1 
Um, it's possible that I'm remembering the recommendation that 50% of all food should be raw (per Enzyme Nutrition and Dr. Pottenger). A standard WAP diet presumes grain consumption. But if you're paleo and eating a mostly meat diet, I guess it translates into 50% raw meat! Weston Price found that most of the isolated groups he studied ate at least some of their animal protein raw. Nourishing Traditions has a few raw meat recipes and says that freezing meat at least 14 days will resolve any issue of parasites. – Rockgrrl Aug 28 2011 at 22:48
2

No.

Raw beef is more difficult to digest than cooked beef. So, even though cooking destroys some nutrients, the nutrients that are left are easier to absorb. Thus, you end up absorbing more nutrients--as a total, absolute number--from a pound of cooked beef than from a pound of raw beef.

Cooking destroys harmful bacteria in beef. Can your body handle a certain types and amounts of harmful bacteria? Sure, but is there any benefit to having harmful bacteria in your beef? Nope, no benefit at all.

link|flag
I was under the impression it was easier to digest raw than cooked.. people I know who eat raw beef say they find way more energy and clarity afterwards. I've yet to try it myself though... – MG Nov 8 at 5:04
No, meat is more difficult to digest raw. – Talldog Nov 14 at 20:44
It's correct that digesting cooked meat is easier. A saw a dog study that showed more than 20% additional calories being absorbed by cooked meat, and they have a preference for it. However, WAPF recommends eating raw meat despite this, and for reasons that your comment does not seem to appreciate or understand. – Chase Saunders Mar 1 at 11:00
1

Sear it really briefly. Very hot pan, very short time. Seconds each side. Pretend to cook it!

Always done this with steak. Now working up, using same method, to eating liver really red!

link|flag
Great idea for eating it in from of my husband. – Blueberry Aug 29 2011 at 14:44
I love blue-rare steak. The risk tends to be on the outside anyway. – ZombieApocalypseKitten Aug 13 at 20:51
1

I try to eat 100% raw meat. There's actually a raw version of the paleo diet, called the 'raw paleo diet.'

There's a web site and a forum, just google search the raw paleo diet.

We eat raw eggs, beef, pork, buffalo. Everything pretty much.

Feel free to check it out. There's a lot of benefits to eating all raw.

Most people who go to raw paleo are battling some kind of health issue that vegan or vegetarian, or even regular cooked paleo didn't resolve.

With raw paleo they've all noticed huge improvements.

Most of us eat a really high fat diet.

For example I eat about 378 cals fat 336 cals protein and 120 cals carbs per meal.

Any way check it out. Its a huge step forward from regular paleo.

link|flag
0

http://www.keeperofthehome.org/2008/07/the-health-benefits-of-eating-raw-meat.html

http://www.keeperofthehome.org/2008/07/the-health-benefits-of-eating-raw-meat-part-2.html

I found these for you..

link|flag
Thanks, I found those too. They are the only ones I found. – Blueberry Aug 28 2011 at 20:55
0

I eat ground, beef, lamb and/or goat raw. 8-12 ounces/day with mustard, mashed sweet potato and sauerkraut. SO DELICIOUS

link|flag
0

I actually find it more pleasant on the stomach. If it's from the right source, it's fantastic!

link|flag
0

perhaps raw meat has much more nutrition and less cooking-induced carcinogenic stuff but what about PARASITES? i don't mind some bacteria or whatever but WORMS!!!

i'd better have a cancer than 10-meter long creatures devouring me from inside

link|flag
0

I really don't see how eating raw meat can be beneficial, it takes a long time to digest eaten cooked

link|flag
0

Raw beef is easier to digest. The proteins undergo a process of "denaturing" where they are more difficult to digest. I am and MD and know this to be scientifically true.

link|flag
0

Number #1 Reason not to eat Raw Meat: Parasites! Watch this video: http://www.markusrothkranz.com/parasitefree/parasite_free.html

link|flag
0

In response to worms with raw meat, as long as it's a tapeworm that lets me eat whatever I want, I'm in ...lol.

link|flag
-2

It may boast health benefits, but contains some risk such as parasites. Plus if you are Christian, Messianic, or Jewish, just forwarn you that it's against Scripture to eat raw meats. Other religions forbid it as well. If you're not religious then... It depends if you want to risk the parasites that could be present, although if it comes from healthy grass fed animals it probably not really a concern. Just my 2 cents.

link|flag

Your Answer

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.