Blog

2

I was once in the norwegian mountains and we had this primitive cooking without pots.

We actually only used sticks and hold them in fire. There are serveral primitive cooking methods on the web on youtube or in surivaland outdoor or priomitive skill books and alll the primitive skill gatheirngs in the USA. RabittStick and Falling Leave and echoes in Time... feral futures. wildroots....

teaching drum....

What ever... why are dishes cooked in pans Paleo? Where did they had the iron in the paleo time?????

When do they discover to cook in pots? When they made the first clay pots??

Do you do any sort of primitive cooking at the fire???

flag

6 Answers

5

Whether or not foragers do have pottery depends a lot on what one selects as one’s “ethnographic present.” Pottery was a fairly common part of the technological repertoire of foragers worldwide until Europeans introduced metal pots and pans, at which point many groups abandoned the use of clay containers. For example, if one relies on the descriptions of the San from the twentieth century, as most of us do, the ethnographies are virtually silent on the topic of pottery. But if one looks at the Later Stone Age archaeology of southern Africa, or the written accounts left by the first Dutch and English explorers to set foot in South Africa, it becomes evident that pottery was a fairly widespread component of Bushman culinary technology (Bollong et al. 1997; Mazel 1992; Rudner 1979). The earliest pottery thus far known appears in Late Pleistocene hunter–gatherer sites in eastern Russia, Japan, and China, with dates as early as ~13,000 radiocarbon years ago or up to 18,000 calibrated years ago (Boaretto et al. 2009; Keally et al. 2004; Kuzmin 2006; Zhang 2002). Ceramics also appear quite early in Africa, dating between 9,000 and 9,500 years ago in the central Sudan, as well as in northeast Niger and Libya (Garcea 2006; Haaland 1992). “In most of North Africa… the production of pottery and groundstone is independent of the origins of food domestication. It occurred about 3,000 years earlier, dating from around 9,000 years BP and 6,000 BP, respectively” (Garcea 2006:201).

  • John D. Speth, the Paleoanthropology and Archaeology of Big Game Hunting

Other containers, made out of gourds or skins, are not preserved in the archaeological record, but are regularly used by foragers.

link|flag
Isn't there evidence of cooking stones? archaeology.about.com/od/sterms/qt/… – Kikilula Aug 31 2011 at 5:28
4

Another ancestral' way to cook is to build a fire in a pit burn it down to coals layer leaves and food over the coals then bury it and leave for 4-8 hours - food cooked this way is beyond describing.

link|flag
Will def have to try this sometime ! – hellzbelle Aug 30 2011 at 19:53
Oh, gods, yes. A pig cooked this way is divine. Especially if you leave it overnight. – Rose Aug 30 2011 at 20:15
I wonder do the goodies from the bones leak out into the rest of the meat and other food that's down there? So you'd be getting some of the same minerals you get from a bone broth? – Paul Aug 30 2011 at 21:38
1 
@WCC_Paul America's Test Kitchen did a side experiment while working on making a foolproof bone-in pork roast, not only comparing bone-in to boneless roasts, but making a "roast" out of mashed potatoes and sticking the bones into it. The bones exuded a significant amount of flavor compounds into the potatoes; intuition tells me that it's highly likely that the nutrition comes along for the ride. – air_hadoken Aug 31 2011 at 5:38
Awesome, thanks air-h. – Paul Aug 31 2011 at 23:12
3

Regarding bone broth specifically, though none of your ancestors may have consumed it, it's an effective way to replace the calcium, magnesium, cartilage etc. that they were getting from other sources. Tastes good too.

link|flag
4 
in research it's not called broth making, it's called "grease processing" and there is a lot of evidence for it – Bread-Eating Beelzebub Aug 30 2011 at 18:05
1 
Does marrow extraction fall under the purview of grease processing? – Travis Culp Aug 30 2011 at 19:00
Meant to say "marrow/brain extraction." – Travis Culp Aug 30 2011 at 20:12
2

Paleo doesn't mean reenactment, so yes, broth and cooking vessels can be paleo. The word is only a metaphor.

link|flag
2

Just because ancestors did or did not do something doesn't make it good or bad. Your ancestors also probably did a lot more murdering than you plan to, and ate with feces on their hands…

link|flag
2

Charred meat probably isn't so good for you, even though our ancestors may have had more of it than we do.

link|flag
Good point, Jay! – sherpamelissa Aug 30 2011 at 20:06

Your Answer

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.