I've improved my diet and seen lots of improvements in my health (yeah!), but some issues remain.
I'm considering trying GAPS to see if I can take my healing a little bit further. I'm reading the book now.
Just wondering, has anyone had bad experiences with the GAPS diet? Is it something that could only do good?
Question 2: If you tried it, what did it do for you?
The GAPS is great for healing your gut, but I bet it could be improved individually by factoring in these possible downsides:
it encourages yogurt, which will contain dairy protein
it allows some foods with antinutrients
it allows fruit, honey and fructose (malabsorption means it's food for bacteria)
the intro diet and bone broths can be obstacles
it encourages foods like almond muffins
in SIBO (a cause of IBS, Fibromyalgia, fatigue, brain fog, etc) it stands in contrast to clinically proven methods that make use of antibiotics. However, sticking to the diet would probably lower recurrence.
multi-strain probiotics (bifidobacteria) might be problematic in SIBO
it doesn't exclude some FODMAPs
I see no downside or danger since it focuses on gut healing which is what most be need. Beyond that it is very paleo. I also feel the use of homemade chicken broth is something that should be used by everyone.
I believe the GAPS diet is a wonderful tool to heal your gut and correct gut dysbiosis, but like every other diet, it needs to be individualized to your own need.
Start slowly with the different intro stages. Stay at least 4-7 days on each stage so it becomes a true elimination diet protocol. Introduce foods slowly, 1 at a time, every 4-7 days so you will know what your body can or cannot tolerate.
I followed and am still following the GAPS diet (since Sept 1st, 2011) and had great results with my SIBO (my journey here). However, I have to follow a low-carb and dairy-free version of the GAPS diet. I avoids squash, fruits, honey and nuts, but do very well with most veggies, animal protein and fats.
GAPS can be a lifesaver for some...I've talked with people who are having amazing results on Natasha's program. The biggest obstacle or danger seems to be symptoms from over doing probiotics in a gut that is so severely out of balance. Best to just back off a bit, and slow down the process...but the intro diet has a lot of healing potential, just listen to your body, as always.
I think Dr. Campbell-McBride was way ahead of her time with GAPS and the intro phase will be especially useful to someone with severe dysbiosis. I find this talk fascinating and send it to a lot of people http://vimeo.com/10507542
I really don't think there is much of a downside to GAPS other than perhaps the amount of work that goes into preparing foods and not being able to eat much. If you are using all organic natural (soaked and dried) products, any recipe like muffins or pancakes will do no harm, because it is not a processed food in the terms of SAD foods.
I've done (2) 2 week periods of GAPS when I was really suffering from inflammation and having problems, it did help. That said, I need to do it for a bit longer and really get the full healing effect. But I definitely have had some healing effects, just need to stick with it longer.
I have some limitations due to allergies and I don't usually do the yogurt parts either due to casein issues. But that is ok as well, because you really do need to tailor it to your needs for best healing. The probiotics also were hard on me as well, so probably won't do those again either. You have to do whats best for you, only you really know what will work or do more harm.
I have all the books etc. I plan on doing it, just can't right now.
Ok, I see that this was posted some time ago, but I'll comment anyway...
As an answer to your first question: Yes, I think that GAPS can only do good.
As an answer to nr. 2: I´ve been on GAPS for 2,5 years and so have my children. I have seen the biggest change in my children, the older one (who is now 8 years old), in particular. For me it has generally improved all sides of my not-so-great-health and because of the cautious ways to introduce new foods on and after the introduction stage it has improved my own feeling for my health / body. If interested, please read the details of our stories here (the pages on the right side menu): www.wholenewview.com
Good luck to you!
I support most of the GAPS diet except for the part on enemas which can be dangerous. In a recent WAPF quarterly newsletter a patient had written a letter that they had gone to the ER for too many enemas (probably done wrong). I think the food recommendations are fairly solid.