Blog

5

I have anywhere from 3-4 bananas per day (when I have bananas). Is that too much? And if so, why?

flag
3 
If you meet your performance and body composition goals, then, no, it's not too much. – Matt Oct 14 2011 at 13:23
3 
It's different for everybody. Man. These questions are really questions people should be asking themselves. – Dan Sep 13 at 11:55
3 
87 bananas is too much. – Poop Master MC Oct 8 at 20:51

26 Answers

12

Eat as many as you want dude. 3-4 is just fine especially if you are trying to gain some muscle. Eat most of them after your intense workouts.

I ate 5 today for my lunch since I was out and about and was by a grocery store. It's the first time I have ever done this and I would most definitely do it again. A hell of a lot better than McDonalds.

They are perfect in smoothies so eat up! And, they are cheap so if one is on a budget then he or she should allow more bananas in.

link|flag
1 
lol. That's awesome! I should try that some time. Cheap, healthy, and available year round. :-) – Ben Nash Oct 23 2011 at 4:12
41

Thirty-one. The answer is thirty-one.

link|flag
11 
It is definitely somewhere under 30 unless you want to end up like -some- people! – Stabby Oct 14 2011 at 6:01
1 
Why not 32? I may do this one day... why not eat 30 bananas just for one day? Then eat 3000 calories of ground beef and compare... – Primal Toad Oct 14 2011 at 7:21
15 
i thought the answer was 42 – sage_ Oct 14 2011 at 7:23
1 
I was gonna say the same thing – ben61820 Oct 14 2011 at 13:12
1 
::shakes fist:: damn you maurile! you beat me to it! oh, and @primal toad, odd numbers are always better than even. less caloric intake. – jesuisjuba - paleorepublic.com Oct 14 2011 at 13:48
show 6 more comments
5

I'd say up to 2 bananas a day are ok. From wikipedia: "Dr. Haas concluded that bananas enabled the breaking up of starches and the conversion of cane sugar into fruit sugar". So basically, except potassium, bananas have a special property that can break up "complex" carbs, so our gut can deal with such foods, reducing inflammation. Think of bananas as a digestive enzyme for other carbs. Therefore, they should not be eliminated, but I think 4 bananas a day is a bit too much. If you just like eating fruits, by all means do so, but maybe add some variety in there too?

link|flag
It's interesting that lots of tropical fruits (papaya and pineapple come to mind) seem to have digestion enhancing properties. I wonder what the evolutionary/ecological/biological reason is for that? – FED at LiveCaveman.com Sep 17 at 22:57
5

Eat as many bananas as you want, its not possible to over consume them in your case.

link|flag
2 
cliff - are you serious? why do you say this? – Jack Kronk Oct 14 2011 at 14:50
6 
Because that's what I believe to be true. – cliff Oct 14 2011 at 20:48
1 
I'm somewhat supportive of Cliff's conclusion, other possibly for different reasons. For the long-term I like to hover around 100-150g of carbs, but in the short term, and especially coming off of the SAD, lots of bananas will improve the status of potassium, magnesium, and vitamin B6 in the body, which are generally lacking in most people coming into a paleo diet, and aren't supplied as well on a lower carb diet. – Stabby Oct 15 2011 at 1:23
8 
"Because that's what I believe to be true." Oh! That makes sense. Thanks for the explanation. – Jack Kronk Oct 15 2011 at 5:21
3

It depends on how you feel about fructose/starch/calories.

According to Dr. Mercola, you should limit your fructose intake to less than 25 grams per day. Also according to Mercola, 1 average sized banana is about 11 or 12 grams. So, if you subscribe to Dr. Mercola's view, you're eating about double what you should.

My opinion would be "whatever you feel good on".

link|flag
2

I love bananas as they are comfortable on my inflamed intestines.They are easy to digest and good to have before a workout in a smoothie!Limit depends on activity levels and insulin sensitivity.

link|flag
2

I read this as I eat pureed frozen bananas that taste like ice cream....

link|flag
1

Sugar from fruit is probably much better than added sugar. That said, fruit contains a lot of sugar so I would limit it to 1 a day, assuming you're eating a variety of other fruits and sweet foods (chocolate, sweet potato, etc).

My reason is simple: I think it's better to be safe than sorry. Plus, the yanomami are a bit chubby... :)

link|flag
1 
your reasoning could be used to eat more bananas – cliff Oct 15 2011 at 11:58
3 
No it can't. The statement "sugar from fruit is probably better than added sugar" does not imply unlimited sugar from fruit is good (or even sugar from fruit is good). Take a logic class and stop downvoting your superiors. – Jay Oct 15 2011 at 16:32
0

Are you trying to lose weight? How active are you?

If you are trying to lose weight, I'd stay away from bananas completely.

link|flag
Absolutely not. If anything, maybe gain weight, but muscle over fat preferred. I'm low - moderately active. I don't exercise much, but I occasionally go for walks, and cook frequently. – Ben Nash Oct 14 2011 at 3:50
0

Dont eat it you want to shed some blubber but it your weight isnt an issue and you enjoy a shedload of sugar then get them down you.

link|flag
0

I eat at least 15 bananas a day when I'm at a tournament and it only does you good, sometimes there's no other way to get enough calories in to hold your weight

link|flag
1 
A banana eating tournament? – James L Sep 21 at 1:13
Do you happen to play Ultimate? – Smeags Dec 17 at 2:52
0

I think your on the wrong site- head over to 30 Bananas a day:) lol

link|flag
0

they say bananas are bad for you if you eat to much of it. 4 will be enough it depends how big it is. Too much banana can give you head ache, nervous blockage and what so ever. it depends really. better to ask a doctor or nutritionist about it. And, please be reminded that too much consumption is bad for you if you have diabetes because of so called fruit sugar from it. Better to consult a dietrician to be guided accordingly.

link|flag
1 
most dieticians are about 50 years behind the curve, from my experience... – gydle Nov 19 at 8:39
0

2 a day is fine. It's not perfect, but fine. Any more would be going to far.....but i guess its just what ever feels right. I would only suggest one though, if ur trying to loose weight.

link|flag
0

70 bananas a day is too much.

link|flag
0

I found that I could eat like 8 if I eat them raw. If I fry them for 6 minutes, with 2 bananas I'm satistified.

link|flag
0

I am 30 yrs.. height 5'9.. weight 52 kg want to put on weight ..

I consume 6 bananas in the morning with 1/2Kg milk.. and same at the bed time.. is that okey?? pls suggest

link|flag
0

In the name of national security... Do NOT. I repeat, do NOT, eat a truckload of bananas.

"The radioactivity from a truckload of bananas is capable of causing a false alarm when passed through a Radiation Portal Monitor used to detect possible smuggling of nuclear material at U.S. ports."

http://www.nti.org/analysis/articles/radiological-nuclear-detection-devices/

But in all seriousness, none if you have fatty liver disease, as many as you would like if you are not looking to lose weight, 1-2ish if you are trying to lose weight.

link|flag
don't for get kitty litter! – matthew Oct 9 at 9:12
0

bananas have a lot of carbs if your working out its okay but if not you could get fat.

link|flag
0

my record was 22 bananas and that was when i was following the 30bad diet. i felt pretty full on that amount, but saw no ill effects from this. now, i just stick to 2-3 if i'm eating them. i really enjoy them and don't see any problem with eating that amount.

link|flag
0

I've had a potassium overdose once so there has to be a limited amount of bananas to eat a day.. I ate 2 and I want to eat another one but I don't know how many a day I should eat this is why I'm on this site. No one seems to know so I'm going for it.

link|flag
0

How many bananas? Ask a monkey

link|flag
0

How do u have a potassium overdose? Too many potassium pills?

link|flag
0

I love bananas, I cant get enough of those sweet plump bananas!

link|flag
0

I heard a case of eating bananas like more than 5, not sure if consumed in one day or been consuming so much for consecutive days ... and unfortunately he died.. This is because of potassium overload on his body. Too much is also harmful though banana is one of the healthiest fruit. He ate that much bananas as this is the available food source they have because they ran out of food while in a mountain climbing.

one in a while should be ok...but everyday with 3-4 bananas.. i think better think twice... you can always take other fruits.

link|flag
0

Mix it up! Invent new and exciting ways to eat a banana! Try a frozen bananasicle ^_~

link|flag

Your Answer

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.