Blog

4

I don't get the high body fat percentage low body weight people. How does one get this way?

flag

12 Answers

5

By eating crappy food and not exercising.

link|flag
2 
Especially by not exercising the right way. I was skinny-fat even when running 16km/day as an elite endurance athlete. – Adulescens Appetens Nov 22 2011 at 7:07
2 
& i was doing 45 min (sometimes 90 min) spin classes. sometimes every day. what a complete waste of time. my weight was okay, but i had too much BF & lacked muscle. the best thing i ever did was to give up cardio – daz Nov 22 2011 at 10:37
2 
Yeah, I was a skinny-fat bagel and jelly-bean fueled distance runner for years. – gydle Nov 22 2011 at 14:16
Not entirely. I was sedentary and ate tons of crap for years, and I have always been lean and wiry. However I was very young and this probably would have changed over my lifetime. But, I had friends who were clearly "skinny-fat" as young as 13 or 14 (and still are) – animalcule Nov 22 2011 at 22:13
4

One of the engineers I worked with was skinny as a rail, but every morning he drank a big plastic bottle of Mountain Dew. I don't think he even touched anything nutritious. He sat around coding all day and never exercised. Last year he was diagnosed with prediabetes and had an absurd amount of body fat considering his size. He's now on paleo +exercised and has normalized his blood sugar and reduced his body fat.

I think the same lifestyle is responsible for "Hipster belly." Beer + no exercise + little nutrition + carbage.

link|flag
upvote for Hipster Belly – MtnEvan Nov 23 2011 at 2:02
3

Insuline resistance can cause it, low fat, high carb diet, not enough exercise!

link|flag
1 
low fat high carb diet doesn't cause insulin resistance it makes you more insulin sensitive. – cliff Nov 22 2011 at 12:22
2 
actually....high fat/low carb makes you more insulin sensitive. refer to MDA marksdailyapple.com/diabetes – Hoover Nov 22 2011 at 13:29
1 
Mark says fat doesn't get stored as fat sugar does, so what does fat get stored as??? :D He has absolutely no sources and what he says for the most part is absolute bullshit. By desigen high fat low carb diets make your muscles insulin resistant so your brain can get enough glucose. – cliff Nov 22 2011 at 13:51
so if thats true (not saying you are right or wrong) what is up with all this HIGH FAT/LOW CARB stuff? i have definitely found that eating lower carb has helped with some fat loss...but if its not necessarily true then why is everyone pushing it? – Hoover Nov 22 2011 at 14:07
Michelle, that is a very interesting question – The Loon Nov 22 2011 at 17:01
show 1 more comment
3

One way can be continual yo-yoing of weight. Exercise and dietary composition can have some impact on preservation of lean mass during a loss phase, but some loss of lean mass is almost a given. Folks tend to stop the exercise regime as part of the regaining of the yo-yo and gain more fat mass than lean. Rinse, repeat ... that's one way.

link|flag
..especially in older women – The Loon Nov 22 2011 at 17:01
2

Eating disorders - restrict your calories, do too much cardio and lose too much weight (including muscle mass). Then eventually, when you regain, it comes back as mostly fat. Do this a few times in your life and by age 35 you'll be a skinny fat like me.

link|flag
Same for me... by the age of 26 :-/ – diletta May 20 2012 at 17:50
2

Age is the easiest way and the most difficult to avoid/change.

Also, regardless of diet if you don't use the muscles they will atrophy and excess energy will be even more likely to go to fat since the muscles don't need it.

link|flag
1

In my case eating healthy/paleoish, walking a lot every day but no other kind of strength or endurance exercise.

link|flag
1

Thin-fat bodies and the Barker hypothesis: http://questioning-answers.blogspot.com/2011/08/barker-hypothesis-and-thin-fat-bodies.html

link|flag
1

Not eating enough protein, at least for me I think.

When I was really skinny fat I lifted weights plenty, and... nothing happened. I just got tired, and continued to have puny-pre-pubescent-girl-arms and a little pouchy belly (which would have been fine, had I any boobs to speak of, damn you Asian genes!).

Now I eat much, much more of it and have a noticeably (to me) different body composition, without actually lifting that much anymore, at least not on purpose/at the gym/with a trainer. Plus, I grew a butt! Awesome!

link|flag
1

I've wondered this too. I think it's a combination of many factors. Age is a huge one, many naturally thin people who used to be lean enough end up with high body fat in their 30s or later. But I have met many a skinny-fat young teenage girl.

My father, sisters and I are all naturally very thin, but lean and with hard little muscles, despite often very poor habits (along the lines of no exercise whatsoever and lots of calories from crap foods). I've often wondered what the difference is between us and the other very slender women I have known with very little muscle mass and visibly high body fat. Chronic cardio and a diet low in calories, protein and nutrients seem to be an issue for most of them. But genetics have to be at play here as well.

link|flag
0

Going LSD (long slow distances).

Eg., a sprinters body vs a a long distance runners body.

link|flag
1 
Paleo man would go LSD everyday though.... – cliff Nov 22 2011 at 13:46
4 
We know that because their 10k and half marathon times are all posted online right? – San Diego Dude Nov 22 2011 at 13:59
1 
Long Slow Distance is not the same as "Chronic Cardio". Long Slow Distance entails a low-cortisol producing heart rate while Chronic Cardio keeps your heart rate at 80% max for hours on end, triggering cortisol to release glucose from your liver then from muscle breakdown. Long Slow Distance anything burns fat if you do it correctly....most professional marathoners advocate this in their plans. Chronic Cardio can definitely cause skinny-fat but Long Slow Distance probably doesn't unless you're doing it wrong. – maryeeclarkisouthunting Nov 22 2011 at 15:04
typically, what would be a correct walking rate for LSD? – The Loon Nov 22 2011 at 17:04
Walking rate, like a mile per hour speed? Any rate that keeps your heart rate under 75% max I suppose. Mine is 6.37 miles per hour. – maryeeclarkisouthunting Nov 22 2011 at 17:38
0

Long Slow destroys muscle tissue...all distance runners look like crack addicts or just plain look sickly and soft despite being thin. They look like they're wasting away. Sprinters are lean, muscular, vascular, and just plain are more robust and powerful. High muscle and low fat, as opposed to ld runners' low muscle and low fat bodies (abulatory skeleton).

link|flag

Your Answer

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.