I live in the city. Though I've been raised in rural environments, I now live in New York, and have gone paleo to improve my health and enjoy my life more. But does going to a supermarket for produce, nuts, fish and meat really count as hunter-gathering?
To me it depends on how far you walk, and I'm not being facetious. If it's from the car or subway stop to the nearest grocery it's not far enough. If it takes 15 minutes or more on foot or bike I'd call it gathering in the paleo sense.
Bipolar Disorder and Paleo 14 Answers