Blog

3

Winter is coming soon, and with it the need to feel cozy after being out in the harsh weather. In my youth that would consist of a hot shower followed by a hot chocolate and a hot bowl of chunky soup. Now, most chunky winter soups usually contain beans and/or buckwheat to help "fill them out". Since neither are strictly paleo, I'm wondering whether there are any alternatives for beans/buckwheat? Are there any paleo/old-world seeds which can be used to add "body" to soups?

flag

11 Answers

4

Potato is IMO, better than beans and can be added in a complimentary fashion to most soups. Same goes for white rice. If you have no weight or blood sugar issues, a tad of potato once in a while to compliment the meat is probably not a big deal. What I do with carbs is just keep them down to a reasonable level and target ones that are healthier and higher on my favorites list. That means, I choose something I really like and that is more healthy, or I just don't eat em at all. I personally do not eat much rice anymore because I never did super like it in the first place so why eat it! But I am more likely to eat potato once in a while because I really like potato with butter. I also like bread with butter but since potato with butter tastes just as good, I will usually choose the potato instead as it is probably healthier. But I also really like steak and since that is probably also healthier yet, I eat a lot of steak, but potato only once in a while. This way, I eat healthy but am flexible and don't feel deprived.
-Eva

link|flag
4

Carmelize onions in a lot of butter or coconut oil before you add to soups. They actually thicken the soup a lot. Some types of capsicum peppers also thicken up with long slow cooking.

link|flag
3

For cold winter days we like a thick soup with fatty meat, Geese schmalz, onions, kale

Turnips, parsley root, carrots, celery, parsnips can be added for variation...

Spices (not strictly Paleo, but delicious): salt, nutmeg, black pepper, allspice, garlic

link|flag
3

I like filling up my stew with plenty of veggies. Onion is great, as are shallots, turnips, rutabegas, celery, celery root, carrots, potatoes. These are very filling, especially with meat.

link|flag
yup yup, root vegetables really help to make a more "filling" soup. just make sure you have room for the extra carbs in your day. – cloudsinskies Jun 6 2011 at 22:37
2

I made a really amazing chili with lots of butter, ground beef, and many different types of chopped up bell peppers for the chunkiness (of course multiple other spices and everything.)

I feel even worse after eating beans than I do after eating bread so filling it out with veggies seems like a good idea.

link|flag
2 
Just wanted to chime in that while i generally consider grains to be the biggest offender for the general american, i too actually feel worse after beans than grains. I think that may be because of the preparation in many grain dishes - ie that there may at least SOME degree of fermentation/souring/culturing/long baking, etc. In i would say 99% of bean dishes (especially in restaurants) beans are quickly cooked and really tough on the digestion. – ben61820 Aug 7 2010 at 13:56
Could also be that the beans are one of the most highly estrogenic foods on the planet behind Soy and flax. That terribleness you feel may be the surge of estrogen infecting you body... just a thought. – John Aug 11 2010 at 14:49
2

If beans don't bother your digestion and you prepare them properly I don't see a reason to avoid them.

link|flag
1

I am lucky that beans never been "big" in my home, so didn't grow to depend on them. For me not using too much potatoes in soups might more of a problem.

When I want a hearty soup I add much more meat than I would normally, varying types (not just regular muscle meat, but for example gizzards), and I love kale for the filler. In addition to that just regular veggies, whatever's around.

adding sour cream just before you eat is also great.

link|flag
1

Potato Chili.

Several large Potatoes, peeled and diced into small chunks.

Lightly Brown 2 lbs grassfed ground beef

Sauté a Bell Pepper(red or orange best), a large Onion, couple Jalapeño To preference

Dice several tomatoes

A clove of garlic minced.

A healthy amount of Chili powder(make sure it's GF) to taste(some like more). A little black pepper

A dash of cinnamon( too much will overpower it)

Throw it all in the slowcooker on low all day.

Go find something fun to do, fast, and an hour before you plan on eating, find very heavy things to play with. Very heavy is a relative subjective weight. Train fasted.

Then get a very large bowl and feast on your tasty tasty simple creation

link|flag
If lacto friendly, grassfed cheddar on top! – Stephen-Aegis Dec 31 2010 at 13:33
This is also a great meal to sneak some ground liver into. – Stephen-Aegis Dec 31 2010 at 13:33
Are you not concerned that potatoes are so starchy you may as well be eating a bowl of sugar? White potatoes are really insulin spiking. – Carly Dec 31 2010 at 13:44
1 
I've found using glucose sticks that now that I'm insulin sensitive and keto adapted, potatoes don't launch my insulin, post exercise. Glucose doesn't make sugar bad, fructose does. Potatoes give glucose which every cell can use, fructose, not so much. – Stephen-Aegis Dec 31 2010 at 16:25
1 
I reintroduced tubers after losing 105lbs, gained 20lbs of muscle an still have visible abs. – Stephen-Aegis Dec 31 2010 at 16:26
0

If you're looking for a "grain", try quinoa. It's great added to a meat and vegetable stew in a slow-cooker!

link|flag
2 
I looked at quinoa, but disregarded it. My understanding of paleo is that our early ancestors wouldn't've eaten anything that couldn't be eaten raw. Quinoa requires processing to remove the inedible husk, so even though it is strictly a seed I don't think early homosapien would've taken to eating it. I understand it also has a high glycemic index/load which would cause the same problems as grains. – Phillip B Oldham Aug 9 2010 at 6:35
Agreed. But it still seems like a better bet than grains. We are, after all, looking for alternatives, not perfection. You can just sprinkle a little bit in your stew. Yum! It don't hurt nobody. – zohar Aug 10 2010 at 9:51
Plus saponins. Bleh – Stephen-Aegis Dec 31 2010 at 13:22
1 
According to Robb Wolf Quinoa is still problematic due to high lectin content. – Carly Dec 31 2010 at 13:43
There was more food processing going on back then than popular belief would lead us to think. Access to fire and the use of grinding stones goes waaaay back. – Happy Now Apr 25 at 2:35
show 2 more comments
0

I use celery root to replace my beans. I cut them into long strips then into the approx size of a bean. It definitely helps fill out a soup.

link|flag
0

If you sautee zucchini and onions until caramilized, you can puree them and add them to you soup or stew for a silky, smooth body. It isn't as heavy as potato puree, and doesn't dampen the flavors of the soup. Try it! It works!

link|flag

Your Answer

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.