This site looks very cool.
I setup a subscription from Amazon, so the hard part was figuring out how much I use in a two month period and setting it up so they ship me the right amount. :)
Tropical Traditions has the best organic, unrefined cold-pressed coconut oil I've found, and if you go to their website instead of Amazon, you can get it for half off (BOGO), you just have to check the website (usually on sale about once a month) or subscribe to their news letter.
A lot of good suggestions here. But something additional to remember. Make sure you can stand the taste of whatever brand you're buying BEFORE you buy that 60 gallon barrel from them... :)
Vitacost.com has some great prices on organic coconut oil and butter, but Amazon has pretty good bulk prices, I always check both. Vitacost.com has a surprising amount of other good organic items like almond flour too.
This is something of an aside, but get yourself one of these, pour in coconut oil, throw in fridge, and you have premade servings of the stuff.
As far as coconut oil, I've tried virgin oil from Jarrow and Nature's Way, both tasting equally good.
I get mine from Mountain rose herbs for $32 a gallon
you can also get 5 gallon for $128
I live in the same state and end up driving by so I don't even pay shipping